6 ms·
How to build a fairer city (2014)
- dj-wonk 12y agoI'm trying to unpack the authors' definition of "fairness". These are the relevant sections I've found: > Fairness is not summed up in Gini coefficients of income inequality, but in access to the foundational goods and services that all citizens should enjoy. > But we believe it is time to think radically about delivering fairness not by redistributing income or reforming schools, but by re-organising sectors of the economy. > The centre-left’s nostalgic attachment to redistributive taxation has faded, and all parties now increasingly problematise fairness as a matter of managing internal competition: the result is standard packages of policy remedies whose reach exceeds their grasp. > Either way, the conscience of our competitive age is about “equal opportunities” through policy remedies which, in our view, are necessary but not sufficient for a better, fairer city. > But procedural fairness does not secure substantive outcomes in high-income countries, where the proliferation of anti-discrimination policies since the 1970s has been accompanied by sharply increasing inequalities in the distribution of income and wealth. > Fairness in terms of outcomes is, of course, much harder to achieve than fairness in terms of process on social housing allocation. > Our argument is simple. If we want fairness, then we should focus on the foundational economy and reorganise these activities to make them more grounded. > We believe the emphasis needs to be shifted towards social innovation that promotes a civilised, inclusive city which performs fair outcomes in all its decisions. So far, it seems to me that authors promote a view of fairness that is about (a) opportunity, (b) access to 'foundational' goods, and (c) procedures (i.e governance). I'm not sure if they put as much emphasis on equality in terms of income and wealth.
- dj-wonk 12y agoA re-reading suggests that the authors are less concerned by inequalities in income or wealth. See "2. Stop fixating on redistributive policies which will not deliver fairness, and start thinking about reorganising policies which build a grounded economy in the areas which are not exposed to competition." In other words, just moving money around to equalize, say income, does not necessarily affect their core principles of "fairness".
- LukeCioffi 12y agoReducing friction to get basic services seems to define their focus on fairness. Income can be one source of friction, so moving money around can theoretically reduce that friction. Better and more efficient design would probably be better because it reduces friction from the beginning.
- LukeCioffi 12y agoI'd summarize the article with these quotes: "Our argument is simple. If we want fairness, then we should focus on the foundational economy and reorganise these activities to make them more grounded. This requires new kinds of policies which build on the naturally sheltered part of the economy and more or less reverse the operating principles of your local city hall as it has pursued competitiveness." "Locally relevant improvements have to be defined without the one-size-fits-all assumptions of competition: dedicated bike lanes are not an issue in sprawling megacities or towns built on steep hills. In many low-income cities, access and pricing for basic utility services is an issue for edge-of-city informal settlements that lack utility infrastructure and/or require long-distance commuting; in a cold, high-income country with old housing stock, the priority might be short term measures that alleviated fuel poverty and longer term issues about financing necessary investments in secure, sustainable energy supply. In most cities, building or buying social housing and capillary transport improvement will be objectives which are interconnected physically and in terms of pricing decisions." "The grounded city is instead a site of diverse experiments and learning which could and should be publicly led." "Drawing on thinking from science and technology studies, government is about experimenting; experimenting is about learning; learning is about building on successes but also about making mistakes; and learning is also about recognising these as mistakes, and moving on." "The point of fragility in all this is not the coherence and integrity of our vision of the grounded city; the question is about whether it is possible to put together a coalition of city government and civil society to get things done. We live in an era of post-democracy which has removed many of the pressures on city governments world-wide to act radically. Hence the lazy default pursuit of competitive success will continue for a little longer, though not without challenge by a new ideal."
- LukeCioffi 12y agoI found the focus on experiments interesting, as it parallels the Lean Startup approach.