3 ms·
> Does your doctor prescribe your caffeine and alcohol? Strawman. I said “or be deemed safe for sale over the counter”. > many people have the experience of
by teddyh 12y ago
> Does your doctor prescribe your caffeine and alcohol?
Strawman. I said “or be deemed safe for sale over the counter”.
> many people have the experience of going to a doctor, getting diagnosed with something moderately uncommon, and going through a trial-and-error treatment process where they are guiding what happens as much or more than the doctor.
The key word here are, I think, “going to a doctor”, as opposed to unsupervised self-medicating, or at least without supervision of a trained and licenced professional.
> What is covered by prescription varies a lot from country to country […]
Yes; see my other comment. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8869314 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8869314)
- lfuller 12y agoSince when has alcohol been deemed "safe"?
- teddyh 12y ago“Safe” enough to sell over-the-counter and not need a prescription. Which is what I wrote.
- WorldWideWayne 12y ago> Strawman. That seems very rude and uncalled for. > I said “or be deemed safe for sale over the counter”. You also said "Any medication [that] I use ...". So, are you saying that these rules are just for yourself or that everybody should follow the same logic that you do because you think it's the only logic and that anyone else who follows any different logic is "insane" as you said earlier? In any case ~ I'm guessing you've never tried Marijuana, but what I'm really wondering is if you think all Marijuana users are insane? If the answer is no, then you're obviously contradicting your own argument. Otherwise, I'll have to conclude that you're just being a ridiculously overbearing ultra-conservative dickhead who speaks in one word sentences like "Strawman". > ...you should find some other suitable scientific institution to trust. Why? Because you said so? You didn't give a reason why you think that revealed knowledge is somehow better than rational knowledge.... If I know large groups of people who take a certain drug whether it be Modafinil or Marijunana and everybody reports positive effects...I feel quite confident enough to self-experiment. How am I insane? > To instead trust random people’s anecdotes on the internet is quite possibly the worst thing you could do. Do you have any proof that that's what's happening though? In my experience people don't read one article and make a decision. They typically use this thing called a Search Engine to find out more information about the topic and end up reading dozens of articles, studies, user testimonials, etc.
- teddyh 12y agoThe rules I stated are (as I wrote) for myself, and others might follow different rules (like the one I suggested in my linked comment), but yes, using anecdotes from the Internet as sufficient reason to take drugs seems to me to be insane. (Not necessary clinically insane, mind you, just your garden-variety crazy people type of insanity.) > [Do] you think all Marijuana users are insane? The people who live where it is legal are certainly not insane (necessarily). The people who don’t might choose to place their trust in credible scientific institutions other than their local government or doctors, and those people are not necessarily insane either. However, if you choose to smoke weed for a reason like “all my friends are doing it” or “I read about how some other people claim to be doing it” then yes, that is slightly insane and idiotic. > Why? Because you said so? No, but because it would be obviously better to do what I wrote than to trust a too-small non-random (often self-selecting) sample of stories of unknown veracity. > > Strawman. > That seems very rude and uncalled for. It was a strawman argument. I never called for avoiding caffeine or exercise just because these things affect people’s mood – I explicitly exempted all things which do not require a doctor’s prescription. To pretend I said otherwise and argue against it is a strawman argument.
- wpietri 12y agoThat is not a straw man. My point is that the distinction between "thing I am doing to my body alone" and "thing I am doing to my body with the involvement of a licensed professional" is somewhat arbitrary. Alcohol is not in fact safe for sale over the counter. But still, we sell it over the counter. Having a licensed professional involved on average makes some things better, but only on average, and only for some things. You don't have to be insane to say, "For X, I know better than my doctor." Indeed, that's an important component of people getting optimal treatment outcomes, doctor or no.
- teddyh 12y ago> My point is that the distinction between "thing I am doing to my body alone" and "thing I am doing to my body with the involvement of a licensed professional" is somewhat arbitrary. Then you should have made that point explicitly. Instead, it looks like you are arguing against something I did not write. And yes, the line is very arbitrary. However, that doesn’t mean that it does not exist, or that you are free to set it anywhere you feel like without worry or care. Unless you have the enormous resources to research on your own (but you don’t, nobody does), you should pick some other party which has done so (scientifically) and has subsequently set the line somewhere. And unless you have reason to doubt their veracity, you should adhere to that line. No, “I feel like it, it could be fun” or “I could make more money by using these performance-enhancing drugs” are not good enough reasons.
- wpietri 12y agoThe point was made by the comment taken together. But I did make that point explicitly in the last paragraph. That you took the first sentence as if it were a standalone argument is not something for which I feel responsible. > that doesn’t mean that it does not exist, or that you are free to set it anywhere you feel like without worry or care Speaking of arguing against something I didn't write...
- teddyh 12y agoI still have trouble seeing it – it still looks very much like a classic strawman attack to me. I’ll believe you when you say that this is not what you intended, and that this is not what you see when you read it, but it is not what I saw or see. I think we can respectfully agree to disagree here. > > […] that you are free to set it anywhere you feel like […] I didn’t really mean you personally; I probably should have written “one” instead of “you”. The reason I didn’t is that it flows much worse, and “you” is also often used in that sense.