4 ms·
Because Stallman has never given a fig for the users, just the programmer-gods.
by TylerE 12y ago
Because Stallman has never given a fig for the users, just the programmer-gods.
- ralmidani 12y agoThe point of copyleft is to protect users from being oppressed by programmers.
- _ak 12y agoCopyleft is a collectivist ideology, it only ever cares about users as an anonymous mass, but not about individuals with individual needs and constraints.
- dalke 12y agoCopyright is also a collectivist ideology. "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts" is even more anonymous than "users".
- prodigal_erik 12y agoNo user ever needs to be unable to arrange for maintenance of the software they rely on. That only benefits some developers by holding their customers captive.
- smithzvk 12y agoThe other reply says as much, but it bears repeating as what you said is so extremely incorrect. The GPL is and always has been a license that limits the rights of programmers in order to ensure the rights of users. This is one of those, frankly, pretty rare cases where the users actually feel a limitation of the GPL (mostly because people that use Emacs has a significant overlap with programmers where the line between developer and end user is very blurry).
- TylerE 12y agoHow many non-programmer users do you personally know that are capable of compiling a C program from source?
- hga 12y agoThey could always hire other programmers to do that. And there's real value in having that option, or getting software from a community that works like that, most famously the Linux distro scene.
- djur 12y agoNot many people are capable of fixing their car personally, but they do benefit from not being required to go to Toyota whenever it breaks. Nonfree software is like an appliance which you're legally forbidden from modifying without permission from the original maker.
- smithzvk 12y agoMissed your reply. Actually it is pretty irrelevant how many non-programmers are capable of compiling or meaningfully editing the C program. The point is that a programmer cannot (reasonably) edit to restrict you freedom. However, after rethinking what I wrote, I should clarify that while the underlying principles are the same regarding what RMS is trying to do here (limit programmers to protect users), the GPL has nothing really to with this particular fiasco.
- belorn 12y ago> the rights of programmers So adding proprietary license on top of software which one has not authored is a right that belongs to programmers?
- smithzvk 12y agoYes, because non-copyleft Free licenses precisely grant this right. By contributing to that project (and licensing those changes under that license) you are saying that this is allowed.