5 ms·
So because I'm poor, I don't (for cost reasons) pollute the environment but someone who is rich can pollute as much as they want.
by wvenable 12y ago
So because I'm poor, I don't (for cost reasons) pollute the environment but someone who is rich can pollute as much as they want.
- derefr 12y agoNo, that's the inherent state of things before a tax: if you buy 10x more of something (because you can afford it), you'll be responsible for 10x the environmental externalities, but won't be feeling 10x worse about it. A progressive tax tries to make the 10x purchase sting the rich person who made it more than the 1x purchase stings the poor person who made it.
- seanp2k2 12y agoYup, this has always been the case. Also, if you have more money, you can and probably do travel more, which is also worse for the environment. You'll probably have a bigger house which uses more energy. You'll probably have more stuff which took energy to make. You'll likely eat out more, which involves transportation of you to a place to eat, other people there to prepare your food, ingredients to the place, waste from dishes, etc etc etc. And if you're wealthy, you'll probably want to not just have all that die with you, so you'll likely do one of the worst things possible for the environment and have a kid or three, who will go on to pollute the world for the next 100+ years.
- zo1 12y agoI wonder, you seem to have some sort of magical wand that conjures money and wealth out of nowhere, to support your argument. Bear with me: Those wealthy people that you so complain about spending their money, earned their money through some sort of market process. (Aside from obvious criminal behavior). Those market processes are the accumulated spending of (probably poor) individuals. i.e. The wealth was not generated and given to the rich in a vacuum. And here is your paragraph, rephrased to refer to those market masses instead of the targeted rich: All those individuals had money, they had to move around. They had a house/shack/apartment, that used energy (aside from hut-dwellers). They have stuff which takes energy to make, and use also. They also have to eat, which involves transportation to the place to eat, people to prepare it, ingredients to place, waste from dishes, etc etc etc. And if they're living (which they probably are), they'll probably want to have a few kids, which is one of the worst things possible for the environment and have a kid or three, who will go on to pollute the world for the next 100+ years.
- latch 12y agoSomeone with money gets to consume more than someone without. This isn't odd, and I'm not even sure it's particularly tied to a "system". Being rich means you get to fly business class or first class, which means you get to pollute more. It means you get to upgrade your toxic electronics yearly instead of having to sacrifice and make them last 2 years. You can get to eat rarer and presumably more expensive food. You get to live in a bigger house, which destroyed more land, and takes more energy. You get a bigger wardrobe, and a greater number of watches. You can keep your house at 20C during summer instead of 30C. You get to drink imported beer instead of Budweiser. Or, inverse: why does someone rich like you get to pollute with their car, when someone poor like me has to take the bus? This is specifically what the tax tries to address. And even if the super-rich don't care, you end up with a lot of money (and it would be a lot), that can easily result in net gains; assuming your government isn't stupid (you know, like stop putting money into oil sands projects and establish yourself as a leader in practically any other technology).
- bnegreve 12y ago> Someone with money gets to consume more than someone without. This isn't odd. Yes, but taxes and regulations are meant to exert a control how much more you can consume as a rich person. Now, taxes are fine in many cases, but not always. For example, you probably wouldn't want to live in a country where you can pay for a (taxed) killing service. Hopefully, we agree that this would be "odd". The problem here is precisely to decide whether it is odd or not to let people emit as much as CO2 as they want (provided that they pay for the tax). Or if we should put a hard limit on it (i.e. a regulation). I personally think it is indeed a bit odd.