4 ms·
> If K-12 and college are making ever-better American workers then capitalists are using their class power to steal from the working class ... If on the other h
by rahimnathwani 12y ago
> If K-12 and college are making ever-better American workers then capitalists are using their class power to steal from the working class ... If on the other hand ... the problem is simply that engineers keep designing better machines (capital) while our education system turns out workers no better than those of 30 years ago...
This is a key point. People talk about increases in labour productivity (how much output per given unit of labour) but this economic definition doesn't match the day-to-day meaning of the word.
If I devise a new process/system which means that I need only 1 employee rather than 1000, for the same amount of output, that remaining employee hasn't suddenly become 1000 times more productive. (Although it would be measured as such by economists.)
Why should we assume that the capitalist (or the market) would reward workers for such technological progress?
- IndianAstronaut 12y ago>If I devise a new process/system which means that I need only 1 employee rather than 1000, for the same amount of output, that remaining employee hasn't suddenly become 1000 times more productive. (Although it would be measured as such by economists.) Why should we assume that the capitalist (or the market) would reward workers for such technological progress? This is where we go back to the era of Marx and why him and others were advocates of the people owning the means of production. The two eras are similar, lots of automation, lots of inequality, huge companies growing from nothing.
- sowhatquestion 12y agoThis sums up my problem with the article. People who are concerned about inequality (I can't speak for Piketty in particular because I haven't made it very far through his book) are not necessarily concerned that workers are receiving less than their marginal product because their employers have stolen the remainder via "class power." On the contrary, we're concerned that workers are receiving their marginal product, which is a "just" wage from a purely economic perspective, but which is no longer (for the vast majority) a wage that affords a decent life. At least that's true for people like me who put more stock in the economic explanation for inequality (technology + globalization) than the political explanation.