8 ms·
Two big questions for economists today
- Retra 12y ago>A possibility that the Big Thinkers don’t seem to consider is “Maybe colleges aren’t teaching anything of value to employers?” It's not about employers, but about society. Colleges are supposed to be teaching things that are of value _to society_, not necessarily to employers. Employers should be trying to improve society by rewarding people who produce value to society, not to employers. That is how an employer justifies her power to a society that allows her to have a disproportionate amount of it. It is very possible that employers' values are not an accurate representation of societal values. Maybe your currency doesn't accurately encapsulate what your society values? Maybe your businesses are not in touch with who their customers/employees are and what motivates them? Example: I pay rent. I've never received an invoice telling me what that rent pays for or how much I'm actually paying for it. My rent payments are not approval of my landlord, they are necessary for my survival. Yet it gives my landlord economic power regardless of why I'm spending the money. Social values are not measured by economic power.
- SilasX 12y ago>It's not about employers, but about society. Colleges are supposed to be teaching things that are of value _to society_, not necessarily to employers Then why are students asked to bear the $100k cost individually? Kinda hard to justify that level of self sacrifice from anyone.
- Retra 12y agoBecause things are messed up. Economists don't know what money is for, businesses don't know what education is for, people don't know how to fix anything, etc. This is probably one of our 10,000 year problems.
- crdoconnor 12y agoThe justification is that because college students benefit personally from their education, non-college students should not be expected to pay for it. The reason is that ramping up aggregate private debt has a number of advantages to the following two groups: * Large employers would like to see the bargaining power of their employees curtailed. You'll be much more fearful of quitting your job or demanding a raise if you fear spiraling compound interest. * High finance (investment banks, hedge funds, etc.) because they can often figure out a way of being paid to administer debts and use it as fodder for high profit gambling activities (derivatives, etc.). An ancillary reason is that ramping up private debt is a way to give a quick economic and employment boost because it usually increases aggregate spending. The public can be boiled like a frog.
- vph 12y agoIf you want to go to "brand name" universities, then yes $100K easily. But if you want to seek an education, state universities are much cheaper.
- vph 12y agoIf you want to go to "brand name" universities, then yes $100K easily. But if you want to seek an education, state universities are much cheaper.
- thesagan 12y agoWithout going into any detail (it's late for me), it smacks of paying up-front for some sort of lifetime employment insurance policy. (Probably a bad analogy, but it's an attempt)
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoSo that lending to students can replace direct state funding as society's means of providing broad access to higher education.
- rahimnathwani 12y ago> Colleges are supposed to be teaching things that are of value _to society_ Not everyone agrees with you. - Employers may think colleges should teach things of value to them - Students may think colleges should teach things which will increase their lifetime earnings - Government may think colleges should educate people to be good citizens (by whatever definition) - College professors may think colleges are supposed to be teaching things of interest to them, regardless of the benefit to anyone else
- Retra 12y agoAll of those things are valuable to society, but not all of those things generate economic value. That is why I am saying it is a problem to conflate societal value with economic value. Schools don't exist solely to support the economy, so it would be a mistake to demand education reform on the basis of economics alone.
- thesagan 12y agoSeems to me that college is a lot of things to a lot of people, and it's probably important that these expectations and measures of results are explained as understandably and universally as possible between all these groups and interests. I'm not sure we're there yet. (Not disagreeing with your post, btw)
- wmf 12y agoIMO any kind of universal knowledge (e.g. how to participate in democracy) should be taught in high school, preferably before the age when people are allowed to drop out. I think there's a social value to having an "intellectual class" (for lack of a better term) created by college education, but maybe it doesn't need to be a large fraction of the population.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>IMO any kind of universal knowledge (e.g. how to participate in democracy) should be taught in high school Participation in democracy comes naturally to people. I don't think the idea that you should fight for your corner needs to be taught for anybody. If it were taught in school, though, you can bet that how to participate effectively (organization, PR, core political principles) is not what would be taught. What would be taught would be "how to correctly fill in the form to register to vote for one of two equally reprehensible characters". >I think there's a social value to having an "intellectual class" (for lack of a better term) created by college education Well, we already have this. This can be counter productive if (a la 1984), they are the most highly indoctrinated segment of society.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoWhat does value "_to society_" mean? Can you provide a definition of this term? Arrows Impossibility Theorem generally says that value to a group is meaningless - individuals have preferences, but there is no consistent way to aggregate them into a group preference. You can get around this with things like cardinal preferences (essentially money and prices), but then the value of knowledge _to society_ is by definition what a person would pay for it. So what do you mean when you say "what your society values"? Is it just a code word for "whatever my team can sneak through the political system" or is there something intrinsic there?
- Retra 12y agoWhat is your definition of 'individual'? A group can have values just as easily as an individual, even if your attempts to quantify that value are necessarily fuzzier. Nothing useful is ever true by definition. Society has values because social contexts promote preferred actions. You start thinking about this by trying to define morality in useful manner: A morality is an algorithm that models counterfactuals and assigns values to them. (I.e., it _evaluates_ possible states of reality and prefers some to others.) Thus group morality is an aggregate of individual moralities, though it isn't necessarily a linear aggregate, nor is it necessarily known or (even knowable) by any individual. Either way, all you need is a hypothetical, because any reliable _reasoning_ you do about group morality is going to try to optimize in terms of flexibility: if there is an ideal outcome for a group, then every action should be taken to ensure such an outcome is not eliminated from potential futures. This implies a lot about group morality. It means information processing is valuable. (And hence, some vague notion of intelligence or creativity is valuable.) Generally speaking, a group is a decision-making entity, and it must value its own ability to make decisions and moral evaluations as a consequence. What is valuable to a society is not some specific state, but the ability to rapidly converge to better states as more information is obtained. Social stability, situational responsiveness, rapid dissemination of facts, efficiency, correctness, etc.. Every society values these things, even if they cannot be used to determine specific behavior for individuals. Arrows theorem says that there is no way for a preferred state to be knowable to an individual. It helps to think of a group as a network of brains in the same way that a brain is a network of neurons. It's a different kind of brain, but it still does all the brain stuff as a simple consequence of the fact that it is a strict superset of brains. Naturally, one brain cannot contain the information of 10,000 brains. (Thus, Arrow's Impossibility Theorem.) But one group can. We cannot know it, but we can presume such a state exists and optimize on flexibility, not state.
- ArmchairEcon 12y agoLet's accept your assumption that colleges teach things that are of value in some non-financial sense. Colleges make society better or make people happier. Then we should expect to see an improvement in a King of Bhutan-style Gross National Happiness rather than a reduction of inequality or an increase in GDP. If Americans aren't, on average, happier than they used to be (adjusted for income), then the conclusion should be "there was no return on the investment in broadening the number of people attending college"
- Retra 12y agoWhat colleges teach and what they should teach may not be the same. So it's hard to say "if A caused X, we should expect to see X." You can't just assume colleges teach things that are socially valuable because I said they are supposed to.
- rahimnathwani 12y ago> If K-12 and college are making ever-better American workers then capitalists are using their class power to steal from the working class ... If on the other hand ... the problem is simply that engineers keep designing better machines (capital) while our education system turns out workers no better than those of 30 years ago... This is a key point. People talk about increases in labour productivity (how much output per given unit of labour) but this economic definition doesn't match the day-to-day meaning of the word. If I devise a new process/system which means that I need only 1 employee rather than 1000, for the same amount of output, that remaining employee hasn't suddenly become 1000 times more productive. (Although it would be measured as such by economists.) Why should we assume that the capitalist (or the market) would reward workers for such technological progress?
- IndianAstronaut 12y ago>If I devise a new process/system which means that I need only 1 employee rather than 1000, for the same amount of output, that remaining employee hasn't suddenly become 1000 times more productive. (Although it would be measured as such by economists.) Why should we assume that the capitalist (or the market) would reward workers for such technological progress? This is where we go back to the era of Marx and why him and others were advocates of the people owning the means of production. The two eras are similar, lots of automation, lots of inequality, huge companies growing from nothing.
- sowhatquestion 12y agoThis sums up my problem with the article. People who are concerned about inequality (I can't speak for Piketty in particular because I haven't made it very far through his book) are not necessarily concerned that workers are receiving less than their marginal product because their employers have stolen the remainder via "class power." On the contrary, we're concerned that workers are receiving their marginal product, which is a "just" wage from a purely economic perspective, but which is no longer (for the vast majority) a wage that affords a decent life. At least that's true for people like me who put more stock in the economic explanation for inequality (technology + globalization) than the political explanation.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>Ackerman’s point of view that economists were infallible and their suggestions should be adopted uncritically by voters was called into question by the fact that the group neglected to book the most popular speakers, such as Thomas Piketty, into sufficiently large rooms and, though they were videotaping the talks, did not have any provision to show the videos in real-time on screens in lobbies or other rooms. If the nation’s top economists can’t estimate demand for talks by economists can we trust them to tell us what to do about global warming? I think this touches on the core elephant in the room with modern (especially American) economics. There is often a lot more money and career advancement to be made as an economist if you are productively wrong - making policy proscriptions that serve an agenda, than if you are right. Of course it does none of them any good to admit that. State this aloud and expect to be ostracized at a conference like this. It would be helpful to look at economists themselves as rational agents who produce an output (political opinions with the veneer of objectivity) and who respond to incentives. Bearing in mind that the employment/income options for most economists are: * Academic departments, funded via student debt. * Think tanks - nearly all funded by large corporations and high net worth individuals. * Finance - large banks, hedge funds, etc. Large corporations usually have different agendas but will seek to form cohesive blocs to increase their power, often under the umbrella of a lobby group. Sometimes they will fight, though. Examples: * Exxon cares about discrediting climate change. * Power companies want solar panels dead yesterday. * Comcast wants net neutrality dead. * Google and Netflix want net neutrality alive. * Google's founders want something done about climate change (as do many notable high net worth individuals from a non-fossil fuel background). * Private colleges want the federal government to keep increasing loans to students. * Corporations that employ a lot of people and are under threat from unionization would like to see workers' bargaining power curtailed (debt is good at that). * Everybody in high finance likes debt (obviously). Especially if it is administered by them, but even if it is not, because even if it isn't, one day it could be privatized and produce profits.
- dllthomas 12y agoSo, can we change the incentives?
- 12y ago
- potash 12y ago> There may be a market opportunity for an economist to write a big Piketty-style book on climate change. Yale economist Bill Nordhaus' Climate Casino is that book. And his research with integrated assessment models concluded: > The consequences of [climate change] will be costly for human societies and grave for many unmanaged earth systems; the balance of risks indicates that immediate action should be taken to slow and eventually halt emissions of CO2 and other greenhouse gases. And, by the way, this analysis doesn't even take into account tipping points!
- danieltillett 12y agoUntil we as a society face the fact that doing something about climate change required compensating the owners of fossil fuels for not letting them extract them then we are going to get nowhere.
- swatow 12y agoI'm willing to face any fact that is true, but which owners in particular must be compensated, and why? What is your specific critique of the carbon tax that the book proposes?
- danieltillett 12y agoThe reason why we need to compensate the owners of the fossil fuels is that otherwise they will block any attempt to do anything about climate change. Just considering oil there is around $100 trillion worth still to be pumped out of the ground in the next 30 years. All of this oil is owned by someone and all these someone's are not going to sit back and let their oil be made worthless (this is what would happen if we were to actually do something serious about climate change). Unless we pay off the fossil fuel owners they will continue to block any effective progress.
- rwallace 12y agoHave the governments of Saudi Arabia, Venezuela etc. actually been blocking progress? If so, how? As far as I can see, the primary blockers of progress on carbon dioxide reduction have been: 1. Environmentalists, interfering with nuclear energy which is the only full substitute available now. (I'm optimistic about solar and wind, but there is much work to be done before they will be more than partial substitutes.) 2. Zoning laws, particularly in the US, encouraging people to drive far more than should be necessary. 3. The US government blocking (for what reason, I don't know) the introduction of a tax on aviation fuel that would cause the price of airline tickets to accurately reflect the real cost. What are the other major ones? I'm letting the Chinese off the hook for the amount of coal they're burning because they have actually been making a lot of progress; I don't know of any gratuitous blockers there.
- evo_9 12y agoIt's stunning to me that a Living Wage isn't the main thing they are talking about let alone not even on the list.
- Legogris 12y agoI find the assumption that the goal or purpose of higher education should be paying off economically in terms of future employment a foreign one. I am well aware that I could build a much more fruitful career by making a different choice than pursuing the path that I have chosen. I have other priorities in life and I assume that so do most of the people who would, say, major in poetry at a "lower quality college". Despite what some economists seem to think, money doesn't really reflect how a lot of us like to think of "value". Spending a big amount of my time on spiritual development, cooking, sozializing and taking classes outside of my field is obviously not the most rational choices for my career. Why focus on getting more money if I already have enough to get by?
- vinceguidry 12y ago> Despite the evidence that people who weren’t academically inclined prior to college get little benefit from college and simultaneously suffer four years of lost income, The real reason we put kids through four years of college is because nobody wants to trust 18 year olds with pretty much anything, much less a salary and responsibilities. So the choice isn't between college and starting a career, it's between college and whatever bullshit jobs they'll be able to scrape up. If you got rid of or otherwise stopped convincing kids they should go to college, you wouldn't have a bunch of gainfully-employed teenagers. You'd be gleefully recreating the enormous social problem of lots of bored young people sitting around without a whole lot to do. We all know where that leads. Anything's better than that, even something that doesn't really help end outcomes much.