3 ms·
The internet phenomenon of simultaneously granting voice with anonymity has definitely given rise to much more critical, negative discussion, which is ultimatel
by bduerst 12y ago
The internet phenomenon of simultaneously granting voice with anonymity has definitely given rise to much more critical, negative discussion, which is ultimately fruitless and detracts from community value.
Like you said, it takes work to be supportive, and if your voice isn't tied to your reputation, many will forgo even attempting it.
That's not to say the workplace is the same though. Some people have figured out that support begets support, and put forth the effort. Online though, it's almost the tragedy of the commons, where users will take only what they want out of a community without even thinking about contributing to it's value or future.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoTrue enough, but it may be one reason there are comparatively few women in tech. People choose a career for themselves when they're years of work away from being in any workplace. Hacker News is the closest thing that people will get to knowing what it's like to work in tech. Which is unfortunate, since HN is nothing like working in tech. Remember the brogrammer phenomenon? At the time, it almost seemed like that was the direction the industry might be headed. Luckily not.
- jnbiche 12y ago>Which is unfortunate, since HN is nothing like working in tech. Working with SV firms full of men in the 20s is exactly like this. My colleagues are pretty much brogrammers, or overseas contractors (who are similarly young, callous, arrogant, and emotionally...young). And looking at other sectors of tech, things look pretty similar. What area of tech do you work in that is nothing like HN in terms of this attitude? (disclaimer: I actually really appreciate HN as a source of information, and there's an impressive amount of expertise here, but as a social network, it's depressing).
- RogerL 12y agoI don't think this is new, just more visible. Exactly this same culture is documented in Kidder's "Soul of a New Machine", and if you read biographies of Oppenheimer, Feynmann etc the same was going on back in the 40s. Academic math is filled with stories of famous crotchedy 'X' launching a withering attack during seminars. I agree with your latter points; I think social media is making it possible to change this behavior. I.e. I view recent developments positively, not negatively.