4 ms·
Supermassive Black Hole Binary Discovered
- ChuckMcM 12y agoThis is fun to think about on a Friday. Two black holes orbiting each other in a binary configuration. Seems like a great trope for a science fiction 'super max' prison to be right in the middle between them. My imagination is just boggled by what the space-time around such a thing must be like.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoThe article author's name sound futuristic enough to be the protagonist.
- josu 12y agoHe means the author of the Ars article whose name is Xaq Rzetelny.
- RobertKerans 12y agoCulture agent Xaq Rzetelny..
- JonnieCache 12y agoNow all we need is for a millisecond pulsar to float through the middle...
- spikels 12y agoThe experienced length of your prison sentence would depend on the gravity in the cell where you were kept. After 10 years in that cell a 1,000 years may have passed on earth. Might be a good situation for both the victim (now long dead) and the criminal (start a new life).
- Yhippa 12y agoHow weird would that be in practice? The punishment would not only be time lost but also coming back to a society that's drastically different. You'd be pretty much alone in a new world like an Unfrozen Caveman Lawyer situation. How interesting would it be if laws on Earth changed during your stay. If your prison sentence got reduced on Earth you might only be in there for a few minutes. Interesting stuff to think about for sure.
- cbd1984 12y ago> How weird would that be in practice? The punishment would not only be time lost but also coming back to a society that's drastically different. You'd be pretty much alone in a new world like an Unfrozen Caveman Lawyer situation. "Modern society can neither use you as-is nor reform you into a productive member. We hope, in the fullness of time, the future society which ours has developed into will find you a more tractable case." It would certainly dissuade people from re-offending with the same skills, at least in a technical and, possibly, social context.
- MildlySerious 12y agoI don't know, dumping a criminal like a murderer or rapist into a strange society that he will likely never be able to call "home" sounds like the perfect condition to cause him to keep going.
- auntienomen 12y agoTo the person imprisoned, this would feel like you had killed everyone they ever met.
- rl3 12y agoAlthough that aspect is utterly brutal, another way of looking at it would be a free ticket on a time machine into the future. If that sort of arrangement existed today, I think you'd see many people lining up for Space Supermax.
- undershirt 12y agonot just any blackholes-- supermassive ones. Some are bigger than our solar system.
- jbob2000 12y ago>Seems like a great trope for a science fiction 'super max' prison to be right in the middle between them. Oh my god YES! This!
- dustingetz 12y ago> Two black holes orbiting each other in a binary configuration ... what the space-time around such a thing must be like If I recall, there is a book about this. Samuel Delany, Empire Star. Absolutely phenomenal. From an amazon review: "The best way to describe the book is to say that it is the literary equivalent of an M.C. Escher print." http://www.amazon.com/Empire-Star-Samuel-R-Delany/dp/0553234250 http://www.amazon.com/Empire-Star-Samuel-R-Delany/dp/0553234...
- sillysaurus3 12y agoThe article also mentions that two supermassive black holes could orbit less than a parsec apart. The Earth is a long way from the Sun, but it's not too far away. So it kind of blows my mind to think that such a small space could pack two of the largest phenomena ever observed. I wonder what happens when they collide? Also, this seems like a great place to ask any physicists that may be reading: Is there consensus about whether you could live inside a supermassive black hole? Theoretically, you should be able to cross the event horizon and be quite comfortable (apart from the existential horror of never being able to leave, running out of fuel, and ultimately succumbing to spaghettification). However, some models predict that you'd be instantly ripped apart: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firewall_%28physics%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firewall_%28physics%29 Which scenario do you personally believe? EDIT: I confused parsec and AU, because I'm dumb. That's like confusing a bread crumb with a skyscraper. But I wonder whether it's possible to live in a blackhole for a little while?
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoEath to Sun distance is 1 AU (astronomical unit). A parsec is over 3 light years.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoHeh. Apparently I'm an idiot. Thank you for correcting me. I'm still crossing my fingers that someone knows whether it might be possible to live inside a blackhole. At least for a time.
- yoha 12y agoWhat happens "inside" a black hole is basically unknown to this day. The fact that you cannot observe something entering a black hole (i.e. crossing the event horizon) does not help visualizing the situation.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoHere's something else I've always been curious about. It's a little bit unrelated to my first question, but I may as well ask. It's kind of a fun thought experiment. In order to answer the first question about living inside a blackhole, one could imagine dangling one's legs into an event horizon and then pulling them back out. If you can do that, then there's no firewall, and it's possible to live inside a black hole. This is obviously impossible, since nothing can come back out of an event horizon by definition. But now imagine slingshotting around a blackhole while dangling your legs toward it. Since nothing can escape an event horizon, your legs (or whatever you're dangling) would be ripped away as soon as they cross the event horizon, right? However, imagine getting very close to the horizon, but not actually crossing it. So, the question is: How fast would you need to be slingshotting around a blackhole in order to dangle something near the event horizon while still being able to retrieve it? Do you need to be going exponentially closer to the speed of light, with respect to how close you want to approach the horizon? Imagine a spacecraft with an extremely long pole sticking out of it. The spacecraft slingshots around the blackhole while dangling the pole towards it. What would happen if the tip of the pole crosses the horizon? Would it cause the whole spacecraft to get pulled in, or would the pole break away? This is probably a basic physics question, but sadly I'm not a basic physicist, as I've shown with my original confusion. It's quite interesting to realize no one will ever know whether it's possible to live inside a blackhole without jumping fully into one, at which point you'll never be able to tell anyone else.
- bertil 12y agoAnd because you always need a threat to get the action rolling: have those two black holes attract each other.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI'm confused. There have been articles posted here some time ago that said black holes aren't real and they don't exist, and there were comments here that confirmed it, as far as I reacall written by people knowledgeable in physics. So which way is it? Do black holes exist or not?
- civilian 12y agoIt would help our theory of black holes if they simply were impossible. There are still some paradoxes that physicists are working out. Her "black holes don't exist" paper would be similar to an old-timey person saying "Planets don't orbit in perfect circles like we expect them to, so planets don't exist."
- antognini 12y agoThere is ample observational evidence that black holes exist in nature. However, there are major theoretical difficulties in understanding the fundamental physics of black holes. The articles you are referring to are about a result by Mersini-Houghton & Pfeiffer from September who performed a calculation trying to understand black hole formation during the collapse of a star at the end of its life. They found that Hawking radiation during the collapse actually prevents the collapse of the star and results in an explosion. This is not my area of expertise, so I cannot comment on how justified any of the assumptions made in the Mersini-Houghton & Pfeiffer paper are, or whether there is an error in the calculation. But as an astronomer, I can say that however black holes do form, they are the simplest explanation for a wide variety of observed phenomena including quasars, AGN, radio jets, and X-ray binaries like Cyg X-1.
- tjradcliffe 12y ago> So which way is it? Do black holes exist or not? Civilian's answer is extremely good but it's worth expanding on. Physicists have a weird relationship with the world, often mediated through theory but deeply grounded in fact. As such, we often attach "theoretical names" to raw empirical phenomena that have a relatively high level of contingency associated with them, and we then talk about those names as if they were the real thing, dragging the whole baggage of the theory behind us. This is really useful as it lets us live for a time in the ideal world of theory without bothering too much about the messy experimental details. We can get away with it because we are committed to always coming back to reality in the end. To outsiders this creates confusion, because we take a bundle of empirical data and label it "black hole" or "dark matter" as if we were referring to the reality rather than an explicitly and carefully constructed theory (not model) of reality. We then reason about that theory and try to find ways to extend it, test it, etc. If it passes enough tests (including tests of internal consistency, consistency with other well-thought-of theories, etc) we treat it as "good enough for going on with", which to outsiders looks like "true", but because science is Bayesian we cannot ever assign a theory a plausibility of unity (which is what "true" would mean, if it could mean anything). There is always room for doubt [0]. So when you ask "do black holes exist or not"? there is no simple answer, because we are in a mixed state, holding contingent beliefs but talking about them in non-contingent ways (because we simply don't have the language or mental capacity to do that.) GR has solutions that would explain a great deal of stuff we see in the sky. We call those solutions "black holes". There turn out to be some consistency issues with those solutions that have recently lowered the plausibility of the proposition "GR solutions with singularities explain compact stellar objects greater than 1.4 solar masses" (1.4 solar masses is about the limit for neutron star stability, so we infer anything larger is a black hole.) So where we are today is that the proposition "Standard GR and QM give an extremely good account of a large range of astronomical and cosmological phenomena that go under the name 'black holes'" is still very plausible, but that is different from "black holes exist" or "black holes don't exist", and always will be. There is a very important sense in which your question simply doesn't address the issue that science is concerned with, which is finding propositions that are maximally plausible, not "true". [0] This is true of all propositions whatsoever, including Bayes' rule itself.
- paulmd 12y agoSupermassive black-hole binary? Sounds like some projects I've coded on... /rimshot
- pavel_lishin 12y agoHere's hoping a physicist is reading this, because I'm curious: what happens at a point where two event horizons overlap? Can such a thing happen? And if so, do you then get two choices of future time-like dimensions, one for each black hole?
- raverbashing 12y agoI think the two black holes merge (at least for the purposes of everything outside it)
- spikels 12y agoNot a physicist but I'd guess nothing would happen when the event horizons touch as the black holes themselves are point objects at the center of thoses spheres. So neither's mass would be within the event horizon of the other. When the central point of the smaller black hole crossed the event horizon of the larger I guess they would merge. Just a slightly informed guess. Would love to know the answer from an expert.
- antognini 12y agoOnce the two event horizons overlap the two black holes will necessarily merge. The "peanut shaped" event horizon of the new black hole will become ellipsoidal as the black hole emits copious gravitational waves. This happens in approximately the time it takes light to travel a Schwarzschild radius. For a supermassive black hole, this could be on the order of a few seconds. This is a consequence of the no-hair theorem. The no-hair theorem states that the only possible stable black holes are Schwarzschild, Kerr, and Kerr-Newman black holes, which are all ellipsoidal in shape (or spherical in the case of a Schwarzschild black hole). When the event horizons overlap the new black hole has a decidedly non-ellipsoidal shape, so it has to become ellipsoidal and it does this through the emission of gravitational waves. Fittingly, this process is known as "balding."
- HCIdivision17 12y agoDo you have a reference to what the shape of these gravity waves would be like? Intuitively, I would guess they'd be star-cracking in magnitude, if the shape snaps that hard. Like, black holes smashing into each other is bad, but the snap from going from a peanut to a pill shape must be utterly catastrophic (I honestly haven't any appropriate adjectives for this - black holes sort of exist as stable catastrophies...)
- geoelectric 12y agoIf I'd only known they'd been looking, I'd have totally helped out: ~geo/Music/iTunes/iTunes Media/Music/Muse/Black Holes & Revelations/03 Supermassive Black Hole.m4a
- j_baker 12y agoI'm kind of reminded of the discovery of the first exoplanet. Once we found it, we started finding more and more of them across the sky. How do we know that binary black holes aren't all that common? For instance, how do we know that there isn't a binary supermassive black hole at the center of the Milky Way that we can't see? For stars, binary systems are very common. How do we know that black holes aren't the same?
- freddealmeida 12y agoI really wish people wouldn't say black holes have been discovered. They are not discovered. They are very theoretical and no one has ever detected dark matter much less observed a black hole. What is observed in behaviour that may be attributed to this theory: it is not proof or even relatively close. http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/01/140127-black-hole-stephen-hawking-firewall-space-astronomy/ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/01/140127-black...
- stouset 12y agoDark matter and black holes have nothing to do with one-another. Even in your linked article, Dr. Hawking is not arguing that black holes don't exist; just that their properties may be quite different from that which they are widely expected to be. There is very little reason to doubt, and in fact there is enormous observational evidence to support, that there exist (and yes, that we have discovered) bodies in space whose mass is contained entirely within their Schwarzschild radii.