3 ms·
I taught high school for 5 years and made the same decision. The biggest factor for me was how the schools were being administered; just a few examples: - Com
by iguanayou 12y ago
I taught high school for 5 years and made the same decision. The biggest factor for me was how the schools were being administered; just a few examples:
- Competition among students, instead of being used as a motivator as piles of research suggests, was specifically DISALLOWED because it might make certain students feel bad.
- When a student fell behind because they were slacking off in class, it was the teacher's responsibility to put in extra time and make sure they caught up, stopping just short of doing the work FOR the student.
- Double standards, administrators demanding that classes be "rigorous", but then when students complain that the class is too hard, or students get bad grades because they can't hack it, that of course is the teacher's fault, and it is reflected in our official evaluations.
- Turf wars among teachers who only care about protecting their own jobs.
- I never had a full time job. Schools will hire for, say .6 FTE, or even .2 FTE, which no one can make a living on. I tried holding 3 teaching jobs at once to put together a full time salary and that worked for about 4 months before things fell apart.
- Working hours of 60-70 hours per week during the school year leads to burnout.
- I make 3x as much as a software engineer.
If it was truly about the students, I'd still be teaching, But it's not.
- steve_b 12y agoWhat, in your opinion, is the best research/study showing the benefit of competition in a high school classroom? Most of what I'm finding online are essentially opinion pieces.
- beams_of_light 12y agoI don't feel that competition would be healthy between students. Some kids are simply not going to be as smart as others, due wholly or in part to genetic, socio-economic, or emotional parameters. Making them feel like garbage on a daily basis at school will not help them at all.
- cheepin 12y agoIf you structure competition as Winner(s) + everyone else (as opposed to a full ranking system), you gain a powerful motivator for competitive students, while not necessarily convincing the others that they are garbage.
- beams_of_light 12y agoCan you provide an example of how this might work in practice?
- relaytheurgency 12y agoI'm confused. Do you mean you made x/3 as much as a software engineer? Average salary for a software engineer here is somewhere around 80,000 and I have not met a single teacher making even that. Edit: Nevermind. As a software engineer you make three times a teacher's salary. I get it now.