2 ms·
I've found the best way to discern what kids are learning at school is to, you know, talk to them for a few minutes. I think the idea of trying to stack rank t
by zaroth 12y ago
I've found the best way to discern what kids are learning at school is to, you know, talk to them for a few minutes.
I think the idea of trying to stack rank teachers and schools works about as well as stack ranking engineers. It's garbage-in garbage-out. The entire premise is faulty.
"You can only improve what you can measure" works great on manufacturing lines and click-through-rates. Not so much, strike that, not at all on humans.
Edit: analog31, exactly that, you are spot on.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoHow do you scale "talk to them"? One person can't talk to everyone. Once you have two people talking, how do you know if person As 8 ranking is really bigger than person Bs 7? Further, if we accept your nihilistic belief that measurement is impossible, how can we know if teaching matters at all? What other sectors of the world does science fail in?
- TeMPOraL 12y agoIt's not that you can't measure; it's that tests (of the type we currently use) are a really wrong tool for the job. Also such big dependence on tests seems to me like the result of people trying to structure out trust from their relationship.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoWhat I'm responding to: The entire premise [of testing] is faulty...Not so much [measure what you want to manage], strike that, not at all on humans.