5 ms·
Most of America’s rich think the poor have it easy
- dscrd 12y ago"Poor people today have it easy because they can get government benefits without doing anything in return" vs "Poor people today have hard lives because government benefits don't go far enough to help them live decently". If you focus on the latter part of the sentences, I can see how it's easy to be a bit confused about which is the correct answer.
- emsy 12y agoFTFY: "Poor people today have it easy because they can get government benefits without having the possiblities to do anything in return"
- zo1 12y ago>"a bit confused about which is the correct answer." Correct answer to what question? I'm a bit confused as to what you're trying to say.
- danjayh 12y agoIt bothers me that the entire premise of this poll seems to be that someone ought to be able to live comfortably on government benefits. Living at somebody else's expense* should be uncomfortable. * Note - in the case of private charities, where the funds to provide benefits are not collected by force/with threat of imprisonment, I'm perfectly OK with providing higher levels of support.
- CmonDev 12y ago"Living at somebody else's expense* should be uncomfortable" Better stop automating things than.
- zo1 12y ago>"Better stop automating things than." Well, then stop preferring cheaper products/services.
- danjayh 12y agoI think that the proliferation of the service industry is a natural response to (and possibly a solution to) the increased automation of manual labor. If I thought it were possible I'd say that the solution was for an increase in knowledge workers (since the automated factories still need them), but many people do not want and/or can't do that type of work.
- CmonDev 12y ago"Living at somebody else's expense* should be uncomfortable" Better stop automating things than.
- CmonDev 12y ago"Living at somebody else's expense* should be uncomfortable" Better stop automating things than.
- CmonDev 12y ago"Living at somebody else's expense* should be uncomfortable" Better stop automating things than.
- nkangoh 12y agoI once had a conversation with someone who described themselves as "rich." They claimed the poor had it easy. I asked him: "If the poor have it so easy, would you switch places?" There was silence. Do the poor not have to pay for things that the rich have to pay for? Yes. Is their life ultimately easier as a result? I don't think so. Coming from a poor background and now having experience with the average software engineer's salary, I'd rather have the latter, 100%.
- techsupporter 12y agoYour question seems to me to be a false equivalence. The word "easy" is perceived as coming from this: A "rich" person sees him or herself as putting a lot into the economic system and, therefore, receiving much from it but he or she also sees a "poor" person as putting very little into the economic system yet still receiving an amount sufficient for survival and some luxuries from it (and, since social welfare is paid for through taxes, also reducing the amount that the "rich" person receive back from his or her economic input). In other words, "those people have food, a refrigerator, a car and an iPhone, how bad can it really be?"
- nether 12y agoIt seems very difficult for one group to empathize with a less fortunate or more marginalized group. Whether it's rich vs poor, white people vs non-white, men vs women, each thinks the others "don't have it that bad," or at least not as bad as they claim. As a straight guy, I found this chart quite jarring: http://cdn.okcimg.com/blog/mofo_mysteries/Suicide-Three.png http://cdn.okcimg.com/blog/mofo_mysteries/Suicide-Three.png (from the end of http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/mofo-and-other-mysteries/ http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/mofo-and-other-mysteries/ ); I just cannot contemplate how isolating and anguish-inducing having an atypical sexual orientation is. To feel badly for marginalized groups is a tacit admission of privilege and unfairness in the world, which makes us feel bad about ourselves.
- tempestn 12y agoPart of why I find HN so refreshing is that the majority of people here, while probably having above average wealth, also seem to have above average empathy. One example is stories about basic income; they tend to get a generally positive reception, even though a basic income would not be likely to benefit most HN contributors. Similarly, the (largely male) community seems to be very much behind making the tech sector more welcoming to women. Those are just a couple of examples of many.
- zo1 12y agoWhat would you say would happen to a budding startup if the founder or key-members acted and felt opposite to the way you describe most HN contributors as being? Is there even a word for a virtual lynch-mob and subsequent media trial? These are very delicate topics, and individuals that are ambitious can not afford to misstep in that regard. Of course, you could be right, and these individuals are simply unusually kind compared to how kind (or not) we perceive the general public to be.
- nostrademons 12y agoA couple years ago, I was complaining about how I don't do feelings or nice gestures because they're "fake"; it felt dishonest to do things just to make other people feel better so they'd have a higher opinion of me. One of my friends replied with a story about a contractor that he occasionally did business with. The contractor had sent him a nice brief note wishing him a happy birthday (or some other special occasion; my memory is hazy). My friend's first thought was "Oh, wow, that was nice of him to remember." His second thought was "Wait, he probably has a calendar with the birthdates of all of his clients on it and software to send out a form letter on their birthday. He wants our business, after all." His third thought was "Well, it was nice of him to setup that software." As separate, individual human beings without the luxury of mind-reading, we can't actually know why anyone does something. That's why people usually judge themselves by their intentions, but they judge others by their actions. If your actions demonstrate empathy to other people, is that any different from actually having that empathy? (As a side note, this is one reason why market economies are so fascinating. It's a system built on the assumption that everyone is naturally self-interested and doesn't care about others that nevertheless manages to make its participants - even the most selfish and sociopathic of them - act in ways that benefit others.)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zo1 12y agoI think the article presents a false scenario. Leaving aside the notorious ease with which some of these "polls" manipulate results by virtue of changing the wording of the questions. I mean, if you really ask yourself what does it mean: "Do you think the poor have it easy?" It's vague, and already has a pre-implied bias associated with it. There's no "yes, but". There's "no" and there's "yes, I'm a selfish rich bastard because my privilege blinds me of the plight of the poor" (if you believe the tone of the article". Most people when answering yes probably do so because they have "some" notion or reason that the poor have it easy in some way. Perhaps they simply believe that the poor should work for the benefits, etc. It all get's clumped under "yes" in their mind, but the interpreter and subsequent reporter blows it out of proportion. What, I personally believe, it boils down to is that the "rich" are not comparing the poors' situation to their own. They're mostly comparing it to the hypothetical situation of the poor having to work hard (I assume via manual labor) to be comfortable or the receive the benefits mentioned.
- scrapcode 12y agoI come from a family of 4 that had a combined gross income of about $45k, if that. We never had Government assistance. I saw my Father struggling at times, but it worked out great. He made it happen. When I left the "comfort" ($26k/yr) of the military, I went from being in what was considered by the Navy as a "Highly advanced electronics technical field" to being unemployed. That was scary. I couldn't find a job. I was eligible for unemployment benefits for up to 24 months!!! I netted $800 every 2 weeks. I quickly got a job as an Office Manager for a business my Father worked for making $17/hr which was a very high wage for the area. A friend of mine boasted at the time about how his Father was now making $23/hr with 20 years in a certain company (for relation purposes). My weekly take home was about $100 more than unemployment. Essentially, at that point I worked my ass off for $100 a week, at what was considered a fairly high wage. There are less than 50 jobs in the area that pay $20 or above, and individuals sitting on their ass are getting paid $17/hr. There is no motivation to get a job. That is a problem that adds to the deficit, and needs to be fixed!
- techsupporter 12y agoUnemployment is not welfare, it is insurance. Your employer, including the military, pays into a pool. People who lose their jobs are entitled to draw from that pool. As you realized, the payments from that pool end after a certain period of time. Finally, benefits and that length of time vary wildly by state. For example, Texas unemployment insurance pays a maximum of $465 per week for a maximum of 52 weeks. The "motivation to get a job" is that benefits will end after a certain time and that time is almost never able to be extended. After unemployment benefits end, you are at the mercy of whatever local social services exist for you. In virtually all cases, as a result of the 1996 Welfare Reform Act, if you are not totally disabled you must be doing something defined as "work," be it looking for work, going to school, or volunteering at an assigned location. That only lasts for so long, provided you are not disabled. At some point, usually between 6 and 9 months, benefits for people who are looking for work and who don't qualify for unemployment end. Then there is what is known as the benefits cliff. Almost all benefit programs have a bright line limit between "qualified" and "not qualified." It is some multiple of the federal poverty line based on household size. If a person or household earns even $1 more than that line, benefits are stopped on that date, even if that is a net loss for the person. A common example: A single parent can receive a $400 child care subsidy provided total household income is less than $19,000 per year. The parent makes $18,500 per year ($9.25/hour) and can pay for rent, food, and transportation out of the rest, but the child care subsidy is a definite need. If the parent works full time and receives a raise of $0.25 per hour, or $500 per year, the child care benefit is immediately forfeit, resulting in a new net expense of $4,300 to the parent. What incentive is there to then take the raise and for the parent to work to improve?
- glenra 12y agoI can't help noticing their survey didn't include the option "Poor people have hard lives because government does TOO MUCH that harms them." Licensing restrictions make it illegal for people with few resources to do many jobs they might otherwise enjoy, zoning laws make it illegal to work from home, minimum wage laws and employer mandates make it hard to get early job experience, price supports increase the price of food, building standards make it illegal to build cheap housing...
- chrismcb 12y agoWhat does "most secure" and "least secure" mean? Without knowing this, this poll is meaningless.
- llewisteam 12y agoI'm sure if they survey the poor, they'd have something to say about the rich people. The real problem here is that there is a huge gap in between. And what are we doing to bridge the gap?