4 ms·
Community College absolutely transformed me and many of my (at the time) classmate's lives. In my case I grew up poor, without much opportunity, and the (again
by bane 12y ago
Community College absolutely transformed me and many of my (at the time) classmate's lives.
In my case I grew up poor, without much opportunity, and the (again, at the time) dirt cheap rates, open admission and guaranteed transfer to a local 4-year gave me opportunity I absolutely didn't have in the few years before I got sick and tired of the dead-end shitty hourly part-time jobs I could get.
Many of my classmates were immigrants and refugees, there to learn English, or get started in their new lives. Now, many years later, they're happy productive citizens, married, with families, working six figure jobs...easily paying off each year what they're entire community college education cost any sort of taxpayer subsidies. Most of them have gone on to get M.S. and even a couple of PhDs.
The doors to get into higher education don't admit everybody equally, but sometimes you can get into other doors if you're willing to go in the side entrance. On the other side, I've worked pretty consistently with people who went to much more highly ranked schools than I did, or came from better pedigrees, and we've all ended up in the same place.
Bonus: my entire college education, from Freshman through my M.S. cost about what a reasonable family sedan cost, and raised my marketability so much that I paid it all off by the time I finished school. I hear of peers, decades later, still paying hundreds of dollars a month on insane student loans, and I feel really lucky to have stumbled into the path I ended up on...despite a little pride swallowing.
- nkangoh 12y agoIt's really nice to see there are others from a C.C. background. For some reason I thought I was the only one (coming into this community I thought everyone went to Stanford, CMU, MIT, etc).
- saraid216 12y agoMost of my friends in high school went to top-tier schools while I shipped over to the local community college. A lack of college-mindedness, arguably. I ended up transferring, but I'm extremely pleased with the education I got there.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoI finished high school with chemistry, physics, and precalculus courses at Hudson Valley Community College in Troy, NY. That helped get me into my honors undergrad at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. I'm currently a grad-student near to finishing my MSc at Technion, the Israel Institute of Technology. I can now hope to apply to certain PhD programs at MIT that I'm excited about, if my adviser here likes me enough to recommend me and I study a bunch more math on my own. Community colleges are awesome.
- verelo 12y agoAgreeing with this. I went through the TAFE system in Australia with my tuition covered by the a low income youth support program provided by the government (Centrelink at the time) and then university (although i never graduated). I would not be who i am today if TAFE was not affordable for me and the luxury of being able to wait for the right opportunity (as i had no pressure from a debt to take anything less than ideal) meant I ended up starting a business that really kick started my career.
- dodyg 12y agoTAFE Queensland + QUT for me.
- danjayh 12y agoSince I'll probably get more than a few downvotes for my main comment below, I'll start by saying that I adjunct teach software development at our local CC, even though the pay (if you calculate it on a 'per hour' basis) is way less than my 'real' job. Adjuncts get screwed, but I enjoy teaching, and appreciate the opportunities that CC gives to students ... I just wanted to frame my comment so that you understand my perspective. Now, on to the part that's going to get me into trouble: I completely and totally disagree with the idea of letting students attend CC without paying. Many students coming into CC, even when they are responsible for part of the tuition (which at most current CCs is only about 30%), struggle to find motivation to work hard on their classes and finish them. Although some students surely would benefit from 'free' college (I put it in quotes because nothing is free -- the rest of us will be paying for it), I do not think that offering free CC is a good use of taxpayer money. Simply put, CC is already heavily subsidized, and I think that if the students have no skin in it at all they'll be less motivated to succeed, which doesn't do anyone any favors. Additionally, for those students who do try, and who do succeed, the potential return will GREATLY eclipse their investment (as you noted). For these students, it is once again totally unnecessary to subsidize tuition because their increased income will more than offset the cost of their education.
- withdavidli 12y agoNot downvoting, there's a legitamate concern about skin in the game mentality. But that's not how it is now. People take on debt by signing a piece of paper, they have no idea what that amount really means until they start paying it off. College loans are too easy to get, 20k here, 40k there, don't start paying until 4 years after. At 18 years old, how many students have experience struggling with interest payments that would take up almost all their disposable income? Another thing is the peer pressure to attend college from an early age. Those that don't qualify for top tier schools settle for 2nd and 3rd choices, sometime state schools, other times private colleges that are basically degree mills charging 30k/yr.
- bane 12y agoI actually agree with you. I also saw my fair share of folks who were not in the frame of mind to appreciate the incredible opportunity they were given. They were looking at CC as a place where only dumb kids go, or that they were better than where they were or were just looking for a place to hang out and meet people to party. I think that people should be paying something to go. But not too much. I've also observed that people who couldn't normally afford CC monetarily also can't really afford it timewise. They're already working 2 jobs or whatever. And the kind of time commitment education requires simply isn't possible. What concerns me also is the continued rise in CC tuition (along with other tuition at other schools). CC works because it's cheap and it's real college. But once the prices start to rise to real college levels, it stops working. I think when I went it was something like $50/crhr. It's well over $150 right now (out of state is over $350). I would not be able to send myself to CC today if I was in the same position.