4 ms·
It's very hard to find a way to retort that actually has the potential to change your mind. I will try, though, and I hope you take this with an open mind. Fir
by scrollaway 12y ago
It's very hard to find a way to retort that actually has the potential to change your mind. I will try, though, and I hope you take this with an open mind.
First of all, I completely disagree. You yourself admit the email was hastily written and that tells me you didn't take the time to actually consider the opposing point of view.
I'm not religious, myself. I know several muslims though, all believers to varying degrees. They all think very differently from one another and have completely different opinions about various parts of islam. One thing they do have in common is that they all condemn those attacks as heinous, disgusting and a disgrace for those people to consider themselves muslims.
You talk about an "evil philosophy" as if this is what islam intended. Plenty of murders and bombings, even genocides, have been committed in the name of a much more popular religion, yet I'm fairly certain you do not think of that religion as an "evil philosophy".
And if you do, please consider that everyone, no matter their philosophy, also have the freedoms you talk about. Those freedoms do in fact include the freedom of faith.
Your reasoning regarding your own thought experiment is flawed. In this world, neo-nazis do not have to fear consequences to such actions. At least not theoretically (which is what your thought experiment suggests), and because neo-nazism is kept off the mainstream media, unlike islam in some countries.
Neo-nazism is not a religion. It's easy to drop the N-bomb on islam comparisons but a lot harder to justify it once you get past the fairly childish prejudice that "they're both extremist mindsets, so they're the same". You've drawn some parallels that most muslims have nothing to do with. Will you find a lot of neo-nazis that follow nazism because they find peace and understanding of the universe in it?
I could argue a long time on how this logic is flawed but I'm fairly certain it won't go anywhere. I just hope that you, personally, appreciate that an extreme majority of muslims aren't merely passive about such behaviour, they're very actively against it and revolted by it. What do you think they can do about it, exactly? Stop believing in their own god? You're removing their freedom of faith if you ask that of them.
I was actually heartwarmed by the european response to the attacks, they have been my own personal light of the past 12 months. I've seen that my country of birth is not as bigoted as I thought, and that its media is in a much better state than I suspected. All of this because they did, in fact, all made a point to make the difference between those wastes of DNA that perpetrated the attacks, and the religion as a whole.
Please don't make the mistake France avoided.
PS: I upvoted you because I'm hoping for some decent discussion on the issue here. I hope others do the same.
- duncan_bayne 12y agoFirstly, thanks for your considered reply. "It's very hard to find a way to retort that actually has the potential to change your mind. I will try, though, and I hope you take this with an open mind." You'd be surprised, I think. I've changed my mind several times on this issue, and I'm still mulling it over. That email represented my current thinking on the matter, quite directly given the speed with which it was written. This is _another_ rushed reply, & I'd like to reply later in more detail if time permits. Some background: I'm an atheist, and I don't (or at least I try not to) distinguish between religious and non-religious philosophies. I happen to think that the greatest religious evil in the world today is perpetrated by Christians against Africa, by way of a prohibition on contraception. Re. freedom of faith, take one example. If your philosophy mandates the execution of apostates, then your philosophy is evil. If you choose to belong to it, to support it, then you yourself are supporting evil even if only by lending it your moral sanction. This is true regardless of whether your philosophy is religious, or not. If your God tells you to murder apostates, then yes, in order to be a decent human being, you need to reject your God - [edited to add]: or, at the very least, find an interpretation of your religion that rejects that mandate. Another example: if you're Catholic, acknowledge the torment and suffering that your religion is inflicting upon the poor in Africa, and change denomination to one that allows contraception. It seems as though you are giving Islam special treatment by virtue of it being a religion.
- scrollaway 12y ago(Disclaimer: I'm an atheist myself. I'll try to make this as coherent as possible, bear with me.) "Everyone has a right to their opinion", as long as it remains an opinion. Right? But let's elaborate a bit on that. Some background first: We, as humans, most likely will never really know the answers to the very existential questions in the universe. If you start asking "Why?" a lot, go all the way outside of the bounds of society, you'll find a lot of very weird questions that you would think you'd get an obvious answer to, but it always tends to come down to "because that's how we defined it". An extreme example: "Why is killing bad?" - An easy question to answer within the bounds of a functional society, but it's not easy to keep answering it if you remove that boundary. Since you're a fan of thought experiments: Many insect species' females eat their mates after copulation. What if our society evolved from such a basis and never quite got past it? You would face the same challenges explaining why not eating your mate would be positive for an established society. (Fun weekend project: Read post-apocalyptic books while keeping such considerations in mind. Authors tend to have a field day with these questions...) Okay, now that that's out of the way: We, humans, do get to define our own ideologies. We get to define what is good and bad, because unlike with mathematics/physics, nature does not dictate rules for philosophy. What I personally believe is that for those potential ideologies to have a chance to prosper, we must never remove their voices. You can choose not to listen to them, but removing the opportunity for them to spread could in fact remove a change for the better. Just like it could prevent a change for the better, but then we go back to the argument earlier: who are we to judge what is good and what is bad? We get to define it, but those that come after us may disagree. At least we have a choice. So no, I'm not giving islam special treatment, I'm just careful of not removing its voice, as much as I can disagree with some of its ideologies (and agree with some others). This is a very tough subject. We don't know where the lines are, different people tend to put them in different places. The law is what we've chosen to draw the lines for us, and we change it all the time. But without differing opinions (christianity, islam, vegetarianism, nazism, kopimism, ...), we can't ever hope to change. And isn't change the reason we are here, exchanging experiences and ideas?