6 ms·
> Always explain rationale around the No, to help them improve This is my inclination: "We liked your attitude, you seem intelligent, and well-spoken, but we h
by humanrebar 12y ago
> Always explain rationale around the No, to help them improve
This is my inclination: "We liked your attitude, you seem intelligent, and well-spoken, but we have concerns about your knowledge of <some key area>, maybe start contributing to <open source project> or experiment in <technology> and reapply in a year or two."
...my concern is opening up my company for legal liabilities. Am I just being paranoid?
- ghswa 12y agoIf you're that worried why not cut it short to "We liked your attitude, you seem intelligent, and well-spoken, but we have concerns about your knowledge of <some key area>." There can't be any risk there, surely?
- sekasi 12y agoI've never had any issues in years and years. I guess as long as you're being positive about it, and try to reinforce the shortcomings versus the positives it ends up being a good conversation. Always do it over the phone, email doesn't cut it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- fecak 12y agoBased on what you wrote, you're probably being paranoid. I deliver lots of 'No' answers as well, and I don't see any issues with what you wrote. Legal liability tends to be around the generic responses where candidates may assume the worst (race, gender/orientation, age, etc.). A specific response that points to a lack of experience in a certain area seems a safer bet than 'not a fit' in most cases.
- sekasi 12y ago"Not a fit" is another way of saying "We don't like you" in a strange way. I stay far away from those sweeping personality statements personally.
- jlees 12y ago"Not a fit" can get dangerously close to "You're not the same gender/race/orientation/age-range as our core team" (especially if that happens to be true).
- daniel_iversen 12y agoYes that is a super tricky one and especially since cultural fit is probably one of the most important things to consider in the hiring process!!
- UrMomReadsHN 12y agoCan you elaborate on what you consider cultural fit and why it is so important?
- JoshTriplett 12y ago"cultural fit" is a rather awful description of a hundred small factors, some legitimate and some not. Sometimes it refers to statements like "commit early, commit often" or "move fast and break things"; that's fine. Sometimes it refers to office interaction, such as whether you tolerate interruptions and social interaction: an introvert in an office full of extroverts or an extrovert in an office full of introverts; that's fine too, though at some point you'll scale large enough that you can't necessarily keep being that selective. On the other hand, sometimes it means "are you going to play foosball with us and drink with us", which is wrong. And sometimes it means "do you have exactly the same personality/likes/dislikes/ethnicity/gender/etc as us", which is wrong and illegal. In general, "cultural fit" is a dangerously vague excuse without a concrete reason. Say what you really mean, and if you can't bring yourself to say it, perhaps you shouldn't be using it as a hiring criteria.
- UrMomReadsHN 12y agoOr... you're not a potential drinking buddy. ;) http://www.forbes.com/sites/susanadams/2012/12/03/employers-hire-potential-drinking-buddies-ahead-of-top-candidates/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/susanadams/2012/12/03/employers-...
- electic 12y agoThis happened at my last company. It does in fact open you up to legal liabilities. The company had to settle 18 cases where applicants "disagreed" with the reason of their rejection.
- hluska 12y agoI think it is a shame when trying to help people opens you up to liability. If that's not a sign that our society is too litigious, I don't know what is.
- WalterBright 12y agoIt's also why companies do not apologize, except as part of a settlement. An apology is an admission of guilt, opening the company to liability.
- acoleman616 12y agoMan, this country is really messed up sometimes...
- click170 12y agoWhat's really messed up is that companies can lose a case in court, and then still not admit guilt or wrong doing. At that point, hasn't the court basically overruled them? They lost the court case. End of story (?)
- WalterBright 12y agoLosing a civil case is not proof beyond reasonable doubt, but a 51% preponderance of evidence. A company can lose a case, and still not be guilty - why apologize for something you're not guilty of?
- Thrymr 12y ago
- gamblor956 12y agoIt could, and you'll want to talk to labor lawyer for specifics about what is and isn't acceptable. For example, when you talk about the candidate "seeming intelligent" that could suggest that appearances may have played a role in the evaluation, especially if you can't narrow down more specific reasons. It's best to stick to objective factors such as the candidate's lack of experience in <some key area>.
- curun1r 12y agoIt is a concern. When we hire, all the "no"s are filtered through our in-house recruiters who have been through trainings on what they can and can't say to rejected applicants. The situation is very similar to giving former employees a reference when applying for a new job. You have to toe the line and be very sure that everything you say is verifiably factually correct or you can be held liable.
- will_lam 12y agoEven if it's not an official response, there are ways to be able to get backchannel information.. only if you're able to leverage relationships you've already built for people working at the company you interviewed with.