5 ms·
That's amazingly frustrating. I bought the second-generation X1 Carbon last year, on the theory that Lenovo had killed off mouse buttons permanently so there w
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
That's amazingly frustrating. I bought the second-generation X1 Carbon last year, on the theory that Lenovo had killed off mouse buttons permanently so there was no sense waiting for a new system that had them; now they release the third-generation X1 that not only has the mouse buttons back, but kills off the insane touch-strip in favor of real function keys again.
- chao- 12y agoI was waiting all of 2013 for that X1 refresh, and spent a whole day swearing at random inanimate objects after seeing what they actually built. Bought an ASUS Zenbook instead. I would LOVE to have somehow lasted this year without a new laptop and sprung for this fixed-up X1, had I known they would correct course. Alas I only buy new laptops every 4-ish years. So Lenovo lost me as a customer for a 7-8 year span because of those asinine touchscreen keys. I loved Thinkpads as reliable Linux workhorses, but the phrase "Will change their usage per app!" might as well say "Will never work in Linux!".
- JoshTriplett 12y agoThe "adaptive" strip actually does work in Linux; hitting the Fn key toggles between F1-F12 and volume/brightness/etc. It's just not fun to use, since it has no tactile response.
- walterbell 12y agoThe trackpad/keyboard change made me so happy, because I can now buy a Lenovo laptop again. Now they need to bring back the Ultrabay (so we can have 2 spindles (1 swappable) + M2 SSD in a 14" laptop) and get rid of non-removable batteries. The customer backlash must have had a substantial financial impact for Lenovo to reverse course. Other than Blackberry, has any technology vendor trumpeted their own course-reversal in launch marketing for a new product?
- DatBear 12y agoApple... The iPhone 6's screen size.
- CamperBob2 12y agoThe entire history of the iPhone is one instance of this phenomenon after another. "Nobody wants big screens." "You don't need cut and paste on a smartphone." "You don't really want multitasking, you only think you do." "Web apps are all you're going to get, and you'll like it."
- huxley 12y agoThe first instance is the only real case of that phenomenon, the others Apple openly framed them as temporary compromises.
- swift 12y agoI might be mistaken, but my impression was that the "web apps only" thing was real and not a temporary compromise. They may have spun it that way retroactively, though.
- jamestnz 12y agoI can assure you that the iPhone as originally announced was never going to allow third-party native apps; it was to be web-apps only forever, and this was not intended to be a temporary position. Even though their language was often cagey, it is my clear recollection that Apple's general attitude around/beyond the release of iPhone OS 1.0 was that web-apps were essentially "as good as" any native app could be, and were therefore everything developers would ever need. As I recall it was some 13 months before they finally relented and began to talk native third-party API access. I was at WWDC 2007, here's what Jobs said at the time - "The full Safari engine is inside of iPhone. And so, you can write amazing Web 2.0 and Ajax apps that look exactly and behave exactly like apps on the iPhone. And these apps can integrate perfectly with iPhone services. They can make a call, they can send an email, they can look up a location on Google Maps. And guess what? There’s no SDK that you need! You’ve got everything you need if you know how to write apps using the most modern web standards to write amazing apps for the iPhone today. So developers, we think we’ve got a very sweet story for you. You can begin building your iPhone apps today." Additionally - Apple board member Art Levinson told Isaacson that he phoned Jobs “half a dozen times to lobby for the potential of the apps,” but, according to Isaacson, “Jobs at first quashed the discussion, partly because he felt his team did not have the bandwidth to figure out all the complexities that would be involved in policing third-party app developers.” The following article discussed this http://9to5mac.com/2011/10/21/jobs-original-vision-for-the-iphone-no-third-party-native-apps/ http://9to5mac.com/2011/10/21/jobs-original-vision-for-the-i...
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> Now they need to bring back the Ultrabay (so we can have 2 spindles (1 swappable) + M2 SSD in a 14" laptop) and get rid of non-removable batteries. Perhaps in the T series, but those choices actually make sense in a thin-and-light laptop/Ultrabook. If you've ever looked inside one of those laptops, it becomes obvious why they don't have replaceable batteries: they put battery cells in every spare space, not in one encapsulated area.
- walterbell 12y agoYes, I meant the T-series, e.g. the relatively thin and light T400S has a swappable Ultrabay Slim which can accept a hard drive, battery or optical drive.
- super_sloth 12y agoThe 8GB ram limit on the X1 and X250 is still pretty crazy. I have virtually no reason to upgrade from my X220 (i5 2410, 8GB/SSD+HD) unless it breaks. Sad.
- MichaelGG 12y agoI'd agree except the X220 screen resolution is idiotically bad.
- ekianjo 12y agoBad for what ? If you had a full HD resolution on that size you would lack proper display on Linux for high DPI screens (it's still not perfect at this stage).
- csirac2 12y agoNo kidding; even my 2010 X61s had 8GB and my 2 year old X230 has 16GiB.
- rndstr 12y agoThat's the only thing holding me back to upgrade my 2012 X1 Carbon. As soon as they release an X1 with >8GB RAM I buy it
- nullc 12y agoSame boat. I finally bought one, after trying out someone elses and deciding that I could live with it. Ugh. It's almost unusably bad. Fortunately I already don't use the mouse much, but it's gotten worse with more use not better. :(
- JoshTriplett 12y agoIt also has severe overheating issues under load; fullscreen video or compilation will hard-hang it, and it won't boot up again for a while.