3 ms·
I'm not an economist, but Japan has accumulated a lot of capital. If they simply invest it well, shouldn't it be able to provide enough income to the aging popu
by pm90 12y ago
I'm not an economist, but Japan has accumulated a lot of capital. If they simply invest it well, shouldn't it be able to provide enough income to the aging population to take care of their needs?
Of course, the economy cannot follow the usual template of growth: more people producing and accumulating wealth leading to continued prosperity for everyone. I don't know what the situation is with Immigration, perhaps the Japanese should consider making it more attractive for immigrants? But I believe Japanese society is very homogenous and maybe not that accepting of other cultures as, say, the US.
- mikeash 12y agoThere are limits to savings and investment. Ultimately, finance is just a game. A really complicated and extremely useful game, but money itself is useless. What matters is what people can produce. Finance is merely what convinces them to put effort into production, and what convinces them to hand over some of the output to other people. For an extreme example, consider if they just stopped having babies altogether. By the time the current crop of newborns reached retirement age, it wouldn't matter how much money they had saved up. There would simply be nobody to take care of them. Ultimately, retirement savings schemes are just a way to address the question of what proportion of future productive capacity goes towards retirees, and of how to convince future workers to hand it over. If the pool of future workers is too small, it doesn't matter how much you save in the meantime.
- jtzhou 12y agoIf Japan and other aging countries created a sovereign wealth fund funded by taxes during "boom" times, like Norway has done, then it wouldn't be as dependent on a pay-as-you-go system. This fund would be held in other currencies and could be drawn down as necessary to keep the local currency stable in the absence of exports. True, much of the domestic economy would be providing care to older people (and few tangible exports) but distributions from the sovereign wealth fund would ensure the Japanese still have a high standard of living. Pay-as-you-go social security systems are the real problem, not low birth rates.