3 ms·
car: switch and lose. Goat: switch and win. Is OK as far as it goes, but it's not enough explanation to cover why you should switch. You need probability in th
by jodrellblank 12y ago
car: switch and lose. Goat: switch and win. Is OK as far as it goes, but it's not enough explanation to cover why you should switch.
You need probability in the explanation because of the two goats/one car choice in part one .. and here I am trying to explain it again. You already know how it works, but you don't see that your explanation of it doesn't explain it.
After they removed one answer, you have more information...
Because the choice isn't balanced...
If it was as simple as you suggest, it wouldn't make a good part of a game show. Everyone would see straight through it.
- Lost_BiomedE 12y agoIt always seemed a bit easy to me without running through probabilities due to the fact that the game show host was forced to choose goat (which is different depending on where the car is). The idea of a forced non-random choice is more clear to me than a probability explanation, but you need probability to demonstrate a proof.