12 ms·
It might be an unpopular opinion, but "I am not Charlie". Even as atheist, some of those Mohammed caricatures are not funny or satire, they are simply over the
by rurban 12y ago
It might be an unpopular opinion, but "I am not Charlie".
Even as atheist, some of those Mohammed caricatures are not funny or satire, they are simply over the line. Not just juvenile, silly or stupid.
In most other countries they would be forbidden. E.g. this one from 2010, who caused the stir and death threat. http://torstenh.de/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/CH8.jpg http://torstenh.de/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/CH8.jpg
France has a different liberal, explicit anti-clerical and anti-censorship tradition. The US and scandanavian countries also. But elsewhere it would be illegal.
Compare them to similar Jesus caricatures, e.g. http://www.zensur-archiv.de/index.php?title=Satire http://www.zensur-archiv.de/index.php?title=Satire
It's a fine line and in some cases german Titanic covers were allowed. "Ein Strafverfahren wurde von der Frankfurter Staatsanwaltschaft mit dem Verweis auf die "Satire" und deren Mittel der "Verzerrung" und Übertreibung" abgelehnt. (Sdt. 24./25.4.2010)"
The legal situation in Germany and Austria:
§ 5 explicitly states to respect the religious beliefs of the population. In addition to the insults of religious faiths (§ 166 para. 1 of the Criminal Code).
Anybody who explicitly agrees with Charlie Hebdo and posts images will probably fall under these paragraphs in those countries.
- johnchristopher 12y agoI believe the narrative behind the meme don't imply that one agrees with what Charlie Hebdo said or how it said it. I believe it's more along the lines of `you only silenced one voice, not our voices` or `I died a little too, even if I don't agree with Charlie Hebdo stances`. edit: the meme originally came from the charliehebdo website. I'd venture to guess that they mean `you didn't kill Charlie. Charlie is everyone`. edit 2: nope, I am wrong according to WP: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Je_suis_Charlie http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Je_suis_Charlie And that's why memes and absolutes suck.
- chernevik 12y agoYeah, well, hate speech laws are themselves a pretty bad idea. Today it's "say nothing blasphemous about the Prophet" and then it's "say nothing blasphemous about the leading scholars". The cartoon controversy was started by Jyllands-Posten not because they wanted to offend Muslims, but because they believed that discourse about Islam and its role in society was being constrained by self-censorship and fear. Their purpose was to open that discourse by re-establishing the right of free speech. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/02/17/AR2006021702499.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/02... The effort might have been dismissed as a juvenile stunt and an unnecessary provocation if the response had been a lot of angry criticism. The violence that has instead followed demonstrates the validity of their concern, and the necessity of their provocation.