4 ms·
"I should have the legal right to kill myself." And of course, even if someone disagrees with that, getting rid of the gun is more likely to change the method
by dllthomas 12y ago
"I should have the legal right to kill myself."
And of course, even if someone disagrees with that, getting rid of the gun is more likely to change the method than the result.
- quadrangle 12y agoI think the stats are that suicide by gun shows far more successful percentage than most other attempts. And I believe there's evidence that thwarted attempts often work out for the better. Essentially, if the only options for suicide fundamentally required a persistent decision over time to carry out rather than a spur-of-the-moment decision, there's an argument that it would be better for society and for suicidal people overall.
- dllthomas 12y agoNote that I didn't say there wouldn't be any improvement. The statistics do show guns more effective than, for instance, overdose. However: 1) it is still the case that the method is more likely to change than the result; and 2) it is likely that means is not assigned randomly, and those more intent on ending their life pick more lethal means - absent guns, some comparably lethal means remain readily available.
- quadrangle 12y agoI'm really not an expert here, but I heard an argument that guns aren't chosen more in some sort of thought-out way like you describe. Instead, guns are there already, and get used by people who realize that there is a gun and they might even not make the attempt otherwise. Regarding suicide, I have much less concern about guns as a method than I do about any sort of lethal tool being available on short notice instead of a situation that requires persistent determination and waiting.
- logfromblammo 12y agoThe ethics of suicide spawns some interesting philosophical conundrums. Would you be justified in entering a time machine, traveling 40 years into the future, and murdering your future self? If not, how could you be justified in murdering your future self without the use of the time machine? Or imagine a person with multiple personalities. Each has a theoretically equal claim of ownership of the body. While one is in control of the body, it commits suicide. Is that ethical? Now consider that your personality now is not the same as it was 10 years ago, nor will it be the same 10 years from now. Your personality may also change permanently or temporarily under the influence of alcohol or other drugs. If you have nothing left to lose but your own life, and no longer care about losing that, would it not be preferable to gamble it in a bid to gains something that you would like to keep, rather than merely throwing it away for no gain? If you outlaw suicide, who would you ever be able to prosecute for the crime?