3 ms·
I see this on the front page of HN, and nothing about the terrorist attacks in France (which happened more than 24 f* hours ago), and I am sad. Granted, these
by iamcharlie 12y ago
I see this on the front page of HN, and nothing about the terrorist attacks in France (which happened more than 24 f* hours ago), and I am sad.
Granted, these events have nothing to do with tech, but I'm amazed that nobody here is willing to show their support for freedom of speech and democracy.
I am sad that absolutely no one upvoted this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8856502 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8856502
- higherpurpose 12y agoThere's nothing at your link. Also, this was #1 for quite a while yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8851832 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8851832
- mtmail 12y agoCurrent news, anything CNN reports 24/7, generally get flagged by users (like me) because it's off-topic.
- hncritique 12y agoI'm honestly slightly annoyed by that pseudo-intellectual, opaque use of the super-downvote "flagging". HN regularily votes boring CSS hacks and fleeting technology topics to the top and hastily flags submissions about feminism, politics and AI, instead of trying to turn them into interesting discussions. There is also a strange aversion against any kind of humor, which does not really suit what hackers stand for either. The reason for this is, of course, to prevent trolling, flame wars and memes, but it seems HN is often overly strict in that regard.
- ihsw 12y agoHave you been paying any attention to HN for the past three years? Plenty of articles about feminism, politics, and AI make it to the top on a fairly irregular basis, but they still make it to the top. And who are you to make a point about "what hackers stand for"?
- hncritique 12y agoYes, I have been here for some years, I know plenty of hackers and many of them are pretty humorous too. I think the HN site guidelines capture the things hackers are interested in quite well: "anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity". Though there should probably be an appendix to match the current state of HN: "… but is not controversial". However, I think especially the controversial things are intellectually curious, for example when Musk and Hawking warn against AI and when three female CS students try to raise awareness for gender issues. I think HN is trapped: On the one hand flagging is necessary to mitigate the constant influx of people who write poor comments which might scare people away, on the other hand it often chokes off interesting topics. What's left is a lot of boring and fleeting stuff, which eventually scares people away too. Fixing this situation is difficult, but maybe it would be a good start to stop downvoting contrary opinions, digressing and humorous comments, and to stop hastily judge other people. What's wrong for example with someone who is concerned that there is not enough awareness for free speech and democracy on HN? If that is his or her perception, why does it deserve a downvote?
- mkal_tsr 12y agoI've never seen a compiler throw a compilation error due to a user's genitalia nor self-identification. Can you link me to which compilers are doing that?
- aw3c2 12y agoThere is no need to post about that event here. You can rest assured that almost every user will be exposed to it in other sources and has a chance to publish condolences there. "Nobody here is willing to show their support for freedom of speech and democracy" is a fallacy. If you know HN, you can see a lot of discussion of these topics, especially when they clash with technology or if technological aspects are touched. Yes, what happened is horrible. But this does not mean that every site everywhere has to participate in the aftermath. There are many events every day that "should" have public awareness, but I feel we should also have the right and opportunity to stay in focused, filtered sub-communities. HN is about "hacker stuff" foremost, not politics, religion or current affairs.
- Simp 12y agoI saw a post about it, shortly after it happened, and upvoted it, but it was deleted.