3 ms·
For purposes of argument: > Books have never been cheaper. Thanks to market distortions enforced by a still-growing quasi-monopoly, whose stock price is only
by smacktoward 12y ago
For purposes of argument:
> Books have never been cheaper.
Thanks to market distortions enforced by a still-growing quasi-monopoly, whose stock price is only propped up by Wall Street's expectation that they will jack those prices way, way up once all the competition has been flattened and customers have nowhere else to go.
> I can video call around the world.
If you and the person on the other end both use the same software out of dozens of options. "Let's see, Jane is on Skype, but Mike uses Google Hangouts..."
> Almost anything can be delivered quickly.
If you live in San Francisco or New York City. If you happen to be among the very few people who live anywhere else, your mileage may vary.
> Email has taken over my life.
As an open platform that can be freely integrated with rather than a closed corporate silo with a cocktail-straw API, email is a remnant of a more civilized age rather than a product of our current one.
> I have free access to an evergrowing encyclopedia.
Whose quality is determined entirely by which obsessive-compulsive editor has the most free time on their hands.
- nl 12y ago>> Books have never been cheaper. > Thanks to market distortions enforced by a still-growing quasi-monopoly, whose stock price is only propped up by Wall Street's expectation that they will jack those prices way, way up once all the competition has been flattened and customers have nowhere else to go. Assuming you mean Amazon here, this isn't the case at all. Wall Street supports Amazon's stock price because they keep growing. They do that by expansion, not by price rises. Wall Street has zero expectation that Amazon will ever raises prices for anything it does - they expect Amazon will continue to cut prices and expand markets. That expectation may be bad for book publishers and possibly authors, but not for consumers.
- maratd 12y ago> propped up by Wall Street's expectation that they will jack those prices way, way up once all the competition has been flattened and customers have nowhere else to go Wall Street will be disappointed. Prices for digital goods always have and will continue to be controlled by piracy. > If you and the person on the other end both use the same software out of dozens of options. "Let's see, Jane is on Skype, but Mike uses Google Hangouts..." In real life, Jane and Mike are both on Skype. > If you happen to be among the very few people who live anywhere else, your mileage may vary. If you live in the middle of nowhere, chances are you have a PO Box at the local post office. Not as convenient, but works just as well. > email is a remnant of a more civilized age rather than a product of our current one. There are plenty of open standards being pumped out. Nobody is using them. Would it be nice to have everything open and universal? Sure. But given the choice between sparse and open ... and rich and closed, I'll take rich and closed. Virtually everything has an API now. How awesome is that? > Whose quality is determined entirely by which obsessive-compulsive editor has the most free time on their hands. How was this not true of the old encyclopedias? At least now, you can do your own digging pretty easily to verify any claims. On top of that, Wikipedia keeps a history of who wrote what and when, which is specifically useful for determining if the editor has an axe to grind.
- williamcotton 12y agoWall Street will be disappointed. Prices for digital goods always have and will continue to be controlled by piracy. But given the choice between sparse and open ... and rich and closed If you've ever wondered why people with no speculative asset interests are so excited about Bitcoin it is because the technology has the potential to monetize digital goods. It also commoditizes identity and creates a rich and singular (yet decentralized and equal access) stream of digitally signed transactions and associated data. A public datastore. Rich and open. It spells out the death of privatized social media over the next decade. My theory is that once our communication mediums are again as rich and open as standing on the street corner and selling newsprint that our intellectual property industries will rebound and thrive yet again. Right now our dominant forums for discussion are privately owned. Facebook, Twitter, Reddit and the rest aren't optimized for quality discussions. They can only quantify and measure in an attempt to subsidize the communication of the people who use their services. We need true public venues for a vibrant intellectual community!
- nl 12y agoMy theory is that once our communication mediums are again as rich and open as standing on the street corner and selling newsprint that our intellectual property industries will rebound and thrive yet again. It's never been cheaper to self publish, either by a blog (self hosted if you choose) or in an ebook. How is selling newsprint on a corner more rich and open that that? You had to own a printing press to have a voice!
- williamcotton 12y agoI'm not talking about price. I'm talking about the fact that it was a public venue. Your self-hosted blog is basically like standing in your own private living room and selling your newspaper. Facebook is like a private indoor shopping mall with no guarantees for free speech. The only way to be heard on the Internet is to go over to someone's private property and hope that they'll let you inside to talk. A consensus database that is replicated completely across all nodes acts more like a public square than anything we've seen before on the Internet.
- mathattack 12y agoI appreciate your politely being the devil's advocate. Some answers below... >> Books have never been cheaper. >Thanks to market distortions enforced by a still-growing >quasi-monopoly, whose stock price is only propped up by Wall >Street's expectation that they will jack those prices way, >way up once all the competition has been flattened and >customers have nowhere else to go. Even in the worst case, today's access to books is much better than ever in history. It is easier to learn about most every topic than ever before. >> I can video call around the world. >If you and the person on the other end both use the same >software out of dozens of options. "Let's see, Jane is on >Skype, but Mike uses Google Hangouts..." Even with multiple standards, it's much better than years ago when video calling didn't exist, and regular calls were very expensive. >> Almost anything can be delivered quickly. >If you live in San Francisco or New York City. If you happen >to be among the very few people who live anywhere else, your >mileage may vary. Even in Middle America, delivery is still cheaper and better than any time in history. >> Email has taken over my life. >As an open platform that can be freely integrated with rather >than a closed corporate silo with a cocktail-straw API, email >is a remnant of a more civilized age rather than a product of >our current one. I'm not sure how to answer this one. >> I have free access to an evergrowing encyclopedia. >Whose quality is determined entirely by which obsessive->compulsive editor has the most free time on their hands. Encylopedia Brittanica (and World Book) had editors too. There you were at the whim of 1 editor per topic. Is Wikipedia's editing really that much worse? It's scope is certainly an order of magnitude larger.