3 ms·
Already in the guidelines http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html is "Please don't submit so many links at once
by tokenadult 17y ago
Already in the guidelines
http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
is "Please don't submit so many links at once that the new page is dominated by your submissions."
I think reader ennui resulting in a more rapid response of ignoring submissions (or downvoting comments) is the best control on this, rather than any automated solution. In other words, I think current community standards of behavior are working well enough on this issue. Automated deduction of karma may not do much to stop spammers, but readers actively flagging spam posts helps, because a sufficient number of flags autokills a post.
- jacquesm 17y agoI know it is in the guidelines, see text above. I'm posting this because it is in the guidelines and that does not seem to be enough. The fact is that a small minority of the users posts a large majority of the links. The last 210 links (and ask HNs and so on, I should have probably removed those), posted. (16 hours, so not a full day): 30 spammer 20 cwan 7 edw519 7 alexandros 4 jacquesm 3 wallflower 3 vincentchan 3 kloncks 3 fogus 3 flemlord 3 dreemteem 3 danw 2 wakeless 2 vorador 2 twampss 2 sinu9i 2 rizzn 2 prakash 2 justlearning 2 j_baker 2 dragonquest 2 bdfh42 2 bastian 2 anon84 2 amayne 2 abraham 1 wglb 1 wattersjames 1 treskot 1 tocomment 1 the_flesher 1 tape4backup 1 surki 1 suprgeek 1 superchink 1 spahl 1 soundsop 1 skmurphy 1 silkoddyssey 1 si2 1 shamiq 1 seven 1 samqam 1 robg 1 rng 1 rayvega 1 rarestblog 1 prabodh 1 papyromancer 1 olliesaunders 1 nulheron 1 noneucitizen 1 nkojoe 1 newacc 1 nakajima 1 muriithi 1 mshafrir 1 mrshoe 1 mmaunder 1 mikefrancis 1 mikecapone 1 mickeyben 1 michekyben 1 mhil 1 mayank25may 1 matthewer 1 mark_h 1 manvsmachine 1 malvosenior 1 mahmud 1 lukosan 1 lmacvittie 1 lionhearted 1 kvs 1 kingkawn 1 kgermino 1 keyist 1 karthikm 1 jv2222 1 joshwa 1 johnrob 1 joepruitt 1 jnoller 1 jimmybot 1 jgrahamc 1 jcthoughscream 1 jayro 1 jackfoxy 1 imperator 1 ice799 1 hikari17 1 hellyeahdude 1 hadley56 1 grinich 1 gord 1 gluejar 1 foxycoder 1 forsaken 1 fookyong 1 davidw 1 damon10000 1 csomar 1 cicoriordan 1 chanux 1 catch404 1 cake 1 brandonwatson 1 blazzerbg 1 blasdel 1 billpg 1 bensummers 1 balend 1 baha_man 1 artpop 1 arijo 1 amichail
- chanux 17y agoreaders actively flagging spam posts helps I agree with this. Maybe some karma encouragement for being on new page might help (Maybe badges like stackoverflow ;)). And also, If there's a flag link on new page itself (not discussion page for each submission) would make things easy in my opinion. Too much submission hurt the quality as I mentioned in an early ASK HN (which was deleted). So I think it's ok to take some steps, at least for a short period of time.
- jacquesm 17y ago> And also, If there's a flag link on new page itself (not discussion page for each submission) would make things easy in my opinion. Yes, that would help a lot. Especially because HN can be quite slow which makes flagging stuff a lot more time consuming than it has to be.