3 ms·
If the cost (in terms of reputation) of printing a paper and subsequently retracting it is lower than the cost of rejecting the paper in the first place, a jour
by onion2k 12y ago
If the cost (in terms of reputation) of printing a paper and subsequently retracting it is lower than the cost of rejecting the paper in the first place, a journal is actually better off printing a dodgy paper and then backtracking later. Ultimately these journals are money-making functions of a business enterprise so they'll usually do what they can to maximise profit rather than quality, apparently even if that hinders the science.
- iansane 12y agodo you think this is just a by product of elite journals being targeted more often, rather than a conscious effort to optimise profit?
- padraic7a 12y agoalthough I think it's fair to say that not all retractions are the result of fraud. I'm not sure about the ins and outs of this case for example http://retractionwatch.com/2014/12/26/nature-cell-biology-insulin-paper-retracted-antibody-problems/ http://retractionwatch.com/2014/12/26/nature-cell-biology-in... but I think it looks like a straightforward revision due to more up to date information. This seems to be a good example of how science should work i.e. scientists posit theory, scientists receive new information and update or revise theory in light of this.