3 ms·
> Note that this situation probably won't get that far. That's because the DMCA doesn't require Google or any other provider to comply with bogus takedown notic
by teddyh 12y ago
> Note that this situation probably won't get that far. That's because the DMCA doesn't require Google or any other provider to comply with bogus takedown notices. And Google happens to have some smart attorneys (at least one ex-EFF lawyer, in fact) on its payroll who are well aware of that fact.
Google removed all URLs except 3:
http://www.google.com/transparencyreport/removals/copyright/domains/github.com/ http://www.google.com/transparencyreport/removals/copyright/...
In other words, Google is not the EFF.
- magicalist 12y agoConsidering that they get requests for something like 8 million URLs to be removed every week, your ire seems a bit misdirected. Safe harbor has enabled the modern web in many ways, but the DMCA takedown process is still heavily, heavily weighted toward the claimants. It looks more like the URLs not taken down were mostly malformed or duplicates of earlier claims and they took action on the rest. Purposefully not acting on DMCA complaints due to obviously bogus takedown notices doesn't happen very often because you generally have to be really sure of what you're doing. Hard to do that when you have 8 million URLs to sift through to find the problematic ones.
- teddyh 12y ago> your ire seems a bit misdirected. Ire? You are misreading my comment. I merely sought to correct the parent poster’s view that Google would not remove anything partly because they have lawyers who used to work at the EFF. The fact is that Google did remove almost everything, and merely employing people who used to work for the EFF does not cause Google to be the EFF.
- greenjello 12y agoYes, but you can certainly automate the process to a large extent. For example, many sites simply don't have the functionality allow copyright infringement. Also many sites will have >99% false positives, whereas torrent sites will have >99% true positives. They could hire a few people to get through as many computer sorted reviews as possible, and the rest of them fall through the cracks.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]