3 ms·
Legal question - If you send a bad DMCA and can't be proven to have sent it in bad faith (so the penalties under that law don't apply), could you still be sued
by Karunamon 12y ago
Legal question - If you send a bad DMCA and can't be proven to have sent it in bad faith (so the penalties under that law don't apply), could you still be sued for negligence, loss of business, etc etc? I.e. you didn't break the federal law, but you still damaged me.
- eli 12y agoI don't see why not
- ubernostrum 12y ago(I am not a lawyer, but did read coverage of the SCO lawsuit extensively) Falsely claiming to hold copyright in a work to which you do not hold copyright may open the possibility for slander of title (which was one of the claims in the SCO lawsuit). I would be interested to see some sufficiently-deep-pocketed entity try to use that to turn an automated-DMCA-complaint house into a smoking hole in the ground, pour encourager les autres.
- dpifke 12y agoSlander of Title (as seen in the SCO case) is generally codified in state law (e.g. Nevada; see http://www.trucounsel.com/index.php/slander-of-title http://www.trucounsel.com/index.php/slander-of-title). Arguably there may be other causes of action, but for a lone a DMCA takedown notice sans any accompanying threats, I believe Federal law would preempt and you're stuck try to meet the bar of intentional malice or negligence. (IAANAL, but I listen to a lot of Jay-Z songs so I know a little bit.)
- otterley 12y agoIAAL (this is not legal advice), and I think you're correct about Federal preemption.