2 ms·
This is a really amazing article. And to readers who are reading the comments first: please don't be discouraged by the negativity. Just go ahead and read it fi
by pm90 12y ago
This is a really amazing article. And to readers who are reading the comments first: please don't be discouraged by the negativity. Just go ahead and read it first.
What I thought strange was that they would have to reverse engineer something that they themselves built? That sounded pretty strange to me. But the article clarifies this point:
"A typical design document for something like the F-1, though, was produced under intense deadline pressure and lacked even the barest forms of computerized design aids. Such a document simply cannot tell the entire story of the hardware. Each F-1 engine was uniquely built by hand, and each has its own undocumented quirks. In addition, the design process used in the 1960s was necessarily iterative: engineers would design a component, fabricate it, test it, and see how it performed. Then they would modify the design, build the new version, and test it again. This would continue until the design was "good enough.""
- nialo 12y agoWe try very hard to do better, but even know this is the normal state of all manufactured products everywhere. One other problem is that mechanical design documents don't have good places for "why is this this way" type comments.