4 ms·
It's really weird. The FireTV voice recognition is innovative and in practice works incredibly well. Also the box is delivered already configured to your accoun
by nailer 12y ago
It's really weird. The FireTV voice recognition is innovative and in practice works incredibly well. Also the box is delivered already configured to your account. Both those ideas are so good they're retrospectively obvious, and you wonder why Apple and Google never did them. I'd buy it again at twice the price.
But the Fire phone? Ugly, overpriced, and nothing that's new is useful. I wouldn't buy it at half the price.
I've never seems company release two things so dramatically different in approach at around the same time before.
- mark-r 12y agoGiven that all his attention was riveted to the phone, I wonder how much input he had in the FireTV product? Maybe the hands-off approach just worked better.
- fpgeek 12y agoFireTV was a much, much easier product to develop. It was pretty clear an Android STB was worth doing. In this case, Amazon wisely took the simplest path to get there: Google TV + better content deals and updated hardware and software.
- mdwrigh2 12y ago> Also the box is delivered already configured to your account. Google does do this if you buy from the Play Store, FWIW.
- Raphael 12y agoApple and Google have had voice recognition for years. Pre-authentication seems insecure. The Fire Phone is priced high with the assumption that the price will be lower with carrier contracts, a la iPhone and Galaxy. Although, if they get the price down, it could become the "free" phone like old iPhones are.
- girvo 12y agoThe Apple TV doesn't have voice recognition. I wish it did, Siri to control it would be brilliant (and it's a lovely machine regardless). > Pre-authentication seems insecure. Do you mind explaining how? Because I can't see it.
- mschuster91 12y agoAll it needs is the postman confusing two packages (or the wrong phone in the correct parcel) and a stranger has total access to your account.
- maherbeg 12y agoDo you really think the password is on the device instead of using some sort of revokable token authentication mechanism?
- mschuster91 12y agoAnd tokens can be abused or stolen (given they're not stored or paired with other tokens/keys residing inside a TPM), we have seen numerous cases of people hijacking others' AWS accounts and using them for mining bitcoin, of all things.
- nailer 12y agoThat's done with an AWS secret key, which is effectively your password to the AWS API, and not a limited use token.
- mschuster91 12y agoI know that, still people have managed to commit their passwords, ssh keys and more to github.
- freehunter 12y agoJust because it's preconfigured with your account doesn't mean it doesn't need a password. My iPhone has my account on it but I still need to type in a code.
- spinlock 12y ago> Pre-authentication seems insecure. Very true but what is the cost to Amazon if it's stolen? They regularly refund thousands in EC2 fees when people check their keys into github. I'm sure there's a loophole where they don't have to pay rights-holders for stolen works and the cost to stream movies is pretty low at their scale. My guess is that the hardware would be the biggest loss for Amazon in the stolen TV crime. It's also pretty easy to crack the case unless the thieves are using a stolen wifi signal too.