5 ms·
So she tried something new, discovered she loved it, and since you yourself love that same thing you're withdrawing her from all other outlets to try new things
by Someone1234 12y ago
So she tried something new, discovered she loved it, and since you yourself love that same thing you're withdrawing her from all other outlets to try new things and focusing her on the thing that you love...
Or to put it another way, she tried web-design and liked it, she could have tried a dozen or more other things in high school (social or classes), but now instead you're dropping all of those opportunities, and putting her on this one unified path at the ripe old age of 16.
Online high school might get her a certificate she'll need for college (and certainly if she applies to a CS program all of this will be a benefit) but she is still missing opportunities to discover who she is and what she loves. Plus making friends...
- skorecky 12y agoAgreed 100%. Why would you take all that away? You can go to school and still learn how to code.
- eanplatter 12y agoI can't disagree more. I wouldn't call high school an 'outlet to try new things'. If she learns to be a developer by the age of 18 how is she tied down from doing anything else? I would say that self discovery is amplified outside of a high school environment not stifled. I also think networking and making friends is also augmented outside of high school.
- zorrb 12y agoThank you. Thought I was losing my mind with all these apocalyptic comments on how a sixteen year old girl dropping out of high school with a cohesive plan, and parental guidance, would suddenly be completely socially challenged and lacking any other ways to gain insights into the world.
- skorecky 12y agoAre her parents going to be her friends?
- KatyaEames 12y agoI can have my parents as my friends, and friends my age. Is it so odd for a teenage girl to be close to the people that raised her?
- skorecky 12y agoIt's absolutely a place to try new things. Sports, Music, Theatre, Clubs, Social Groups, etc. It's much harder to get that experience outside of a place that gives it to you. Outside of high school where are you going to meet new friends? You made friends by doing the activities that the school provided. Because it found people in the same age range that had similar interest. Not every high school is the same, but I don't agree with your statement at all.
- ygjb 12y agoAs a counterpoint, I started programming when I was 5, and have known what I wanted to do since I was 7 (shortly after writing my first program that someone else used). I did my first commercial software project when I was 16, and got stuck in 'trying new things' for several years because people (for example, parents, family, teachers) around me told me that I didn't really know what I want. Doing that set back my career by several years over where I could have been. If this was happening at an earlier age, it would be more questionable, but for the vast majority of human history people already knew what they would be doing for their lives and had training and experience by the time they were 16. She is young enough to change her mind, and will still finish high school. As for the social aspect, did you miss the part where she will attend a different education program?
- Someone1234 12y agoYour anecdote doesn't apply here so it isn't a counterpoint. You knew "when [you were] 5" in contrast to the article: > Last year I kind of coerced my daughter into taking a Web Design class at her high school. Just one year and since 5-7 aren't the same or even ballpark. > She is young enough to change her mind, and will still finish high school. I don't follow. She won't be attending High School as her parents have withdrawn her. > As for the social aspect, did you miss the part where she will attend a different education program? Mostly with people much older than her. Look at some of the programs, they're adult education (i.e. people changing careers, or in-place of college). It is harder to socialise with people in different stages of their lives.
- DavidAdams 12y agoThe article states that she's going to finish high school online.
- rev_bird 12y agoThe general theme of the conversation down here seems to be around how "high school online" is a very, very different experience than "high school in high school." Socially, in particular.
- ElComradio 12y agoThere's an underlying assumption here that there are opportunities to be missed. She's already mostly through HS; this isn't like some isolated homeschooled situation. If you're 16, have an obvious lucrative career path right in front of you, you would be an idiot to spend hours writing AP History reports or whatever, especially if your interest in that topic is low.
- alistairSH 12y ago16 isn't mostly through high school. Unless she's a year ahead, she is/was likely a sophomore, or only half-way through high school. And she's missing the best parts of those last two years - the large number of AP/IB courses offered at most American high schools. And really, I'm not sure why anybody would be in such a rush to get a job. Money isn't everything.
- ElComradio 12y agoHow many tens of thousands of opportunity cost dollars would you pay to attend your high school's AP/IB courses?
- BorgHunter 12y agoThis was my reaction too. School provides myriad things other than simply vocational training—that's a very significant sacrifice. It could well be that this was known, discussed, and the verdict came in that the sacrifice was worthwhile, but I hope any parents considering a similar path would consider the whole meal instead of merely one dish. Another point: You can denigrate the liberal arts all you like ("wasting her time [...] taking yet another history class") and reject the argument that familiarity with them produces more well-rounded individuals, but a big portion of working in any knowledge-based profession will involve writing. I hope this young lady will also be able to have and take advantage of opportunities to become a better writer, because most of those opportunities before turning 18 happen in school.
- Vendan 12y agoReally wish I knew why everyone automatically assumes that homeschooling is useless...
- rev_bird 12y agoI'll give it a shot: I wouldn't say useless at all, but the main reason I won't be homeschooling my children is that I don't think I'm smart enough to do a better job than an entire school full of educators. I'm sure various arguments can be made for whether or not that's true of different people (and teachers), but I grew up in a pretty mediocre school system and still had very smart teachers teaching cool classes that were so, so good because of their very specialized knowledge. I can see how K-8 might be much easier to replace with homeschooling, but I have a hard time with secondary school. If my mom had taught me high school chemistry, for example, she could have gone through the book and lessons with me with minimum difficulty. But I had a chemistry teacher who'd left being a college professor/researcher so he could be back with younger students, and he was amazingly smart and fun to learn from. I'd have missed that completely. The author of the article comes from another angle entirely: It's a situation where the high school teachers' specialized knowledge isn't nearly good enough. I get that too. If I was a quantum physicist, I'd bet dollars to donuts I could cook up a better physics student than your average college-prep science class -- but that doesn't mean I'd be better at everything else that happens in high school, too.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- billions 12y agoYour point is diversifying experiences leads to more qualified decisions. Why can't America diversify educational experiences, to lead to more qualified educational tracks?
- timthorn 12y agoTake a look at the University Techical Colleges in the UK, eg for Life Sciences: http://utccambridge.co.uk/ http://utccambridge.co.uk/ Or for Computer Science: http://www.utcreading.co.uk/ http://www.utcreading.co.uk/ Or for Mech Eng & manufacturing:http://www.derbymanufacturingutc.co.uk/ http://www.derbymanufacturingutc.co.uk/
- brandonmenc 12y agoPalmer Luckey, inventor of the Oculus Rift, was homeschooled. I wonder what opportunities he missed out on. Can he "socialize?" Maybe he would've done something better if he had taken AP History and went to prom. Many questions...