3 ms·
I have to admit, I am sceptical myself. I am familiar with using bioimpedance, and in particular it has been used to guestimate someone's % of bodyfat since fo
by Someone1234 12y ago
I have to admit, I am sceptical myself.
I am familiar with using bioimpedance, and in particular it has been used to guestimate someone's % of bodyfat since forever. I am also aware that it is highly inaccurate doing so [0].
So someone taking an already inaccurate technology and claiming that they're using it at the cellular level (and by extension claiming that eating changes every cell in your body) is going to make me sceptical.
The BBC's test helps a little, but the fact the BBC weren't able to use their own person, test over a longer period, or even gather the results themselves means it has less legitimacy. Cheating isn't impossible given the scenario (*although I have absolutely no evidence they did so)...
Honestly I hope this technology is legitimate. It would be really incredible (particularly has it requires no new/special hardware, just a software update). However until they're able to fund even a single independent study, even a relatively small one, I am going to stay well away (and consider it snake-oily).
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioelectrical_impedance_analysis#Accuracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioelectrical_impedance_analys...
edit: Random thought: The article claimed the device slowly counted up for over 2 hours, then the person had to leave immediately after it hit its goal. Couldn't they have just programmed it to simply add approx. 40 calories every 10 minutes until the magic number was "found" then leave before it shot past that figure? Did it actually settle at the 510 ish figure or did they just end it at that point? The article is unclear.
- jfoutz 12y agoMy reading was, they scheduled 2.5 hours, and he left at that point. So, maybe it did shoot past at the 3 hour mark (or not). Perhaps not lilly white honesty, but it seemed reasonable to me.