4 ms·
Curious -- how is this technically possible? Does Netflix simply maintain a blacklist of IP's they know belong to certain VPN services? If you used a VPN that w
by crazygringo 12y ago
Curious -- how is this technically possible? Does Netflix simply maintain a blacklist of IP's they know belong to certain VPN services? If you used a VPN that wasn't popular enough to be "on the radar" (e.g. your corporate VPN based in the US) would Netflix have any way of blocking it?
- snarkyturtle 12y agoFor the Android app at least, it's manually setting the DNS lookup to 8.8.8.8 (source: http://www.reddit.com/r/netflix/comments/2qevqt/meta_netflix_is_starting_to_crack_down_on_dns_vpn/ http://www.reddit.com/r/netflix/comments/2qevqt/meta_netflix...)
- danesparza 12y agoWow -- so if you lock down your network's DNS (say, to OpenDNS) you can't use the Netflix app in Android?
- Someone1234 12y agoCorrect. But in most places that are doing those types of DNS restrictions they would see this as a win/win, since if you're blocking Google DNS, you're likely blocking services like Netflix anyway.
- JosephRedfern 12y agoIf you/your firewall is actively blocking queries to other DNS servers, then I suspect that might be the case.
- JosephRedfern 12y agoOn that topic: I'm not doubting that they are using a different DNS server, but I decompiled the latest Netflix APK, and couldn't find any reference to the string "8.8.8.8", or any other DNS server. I suspect they might be hiding/obfuscating/encrypting the IP somewhere: http://imgur.com/SNQeEi4 http://imgur.com/SNQeEi4
- Ded7xSEoPKYNsDd 12y agoHave you looked for the integer representation 0x08080808?
- mintplant 12y agoThis could be a workaround for buggy ISP DNS servers, with the unintentional effect of breaking VPN access on Android.
- dogma1138 12y agoGeolocating the IP and comparing it to IP's assigned to ISP's isn't that hard, then it's simply just blocking non US registered accounts with a US IP address which is not assigned to a general commercial or residential address spaces of US ISP's. There might be some issues with people using netflix from within very large corporations that own entire IP blocks and are effectively their own ISP but that's quite a negligible amount of users to begin with. But before people some how blame the US again i have a feeling this is actually powered by non US actors. US firms have no reason to block it, the problem comes when the rights for the content that Netflix streams in the US belong to other entities elsewhere, especially of those entities licensed the content to other competing services. If LoveFilme(Amazon Instant Video these days), NOW, or any other streaming services bought the rights exclusive rights for shows or movies in the UK the last thing they would want is for people to be able to stream them from Netflix using a VPN or a proxy..
- jacalata 12y agoUS content firms absolutely have reason to block it because they want to sell the content to the foreign providers in the first place.
- dogma1138 12y agoUS content firms also sell directly outside of the US, and local providers will still buy it from them as they are the one that localizing content in the first place. Europe is probably the worse place for content distribution on earth due to the massive amount of localization, this means that while Universal might license the content directly in the UK it has to sell the distribution rights to 10 different companies in the mainland just to handle to localization which in many countries also includes full dubbing. Intellectual property and distribution rights tend be quite messy in the unified EU market, especially since the translations are considered as individual intellectual properties, and the dubbing considered a recorded work so you have more and more red tape and various guilds and unions for both voice actors and translators to deal with. And this really really sucks, there are like 50 VOD providers in the EU now but due to distribution rights none of them can get any good content coverage and under many cases cannot offer services across the EU.