3 ms·
> the DMCA was passed through the normal legislative process. Wrong. First of all those treaties took place before DMCA (including 1201) was passed. And there
by shmerl 12y ago
> the DMCA was passed through the normal legislative process.
Wrong. First of all those treaties took place before DMCA (including 1201) was passed. And there was nothing normal about it. Normal process actually rejected such idiotic restriction outright (since DRM proponents first attempted to pass it normally).
When they were kicked by normal democratic process, they turned to WIPO treaties which have no democratic oversight. Corruption there is much easier, so they squeezed anticircumvention provisions into such treaties affecting US. Then they turned back to the Congress and said: "you can't ignore your international obligations! Pass this law". And Congress passed it without much of opposition. That's not called a normal democratic process, it's called corruption and backdoor dealing.
See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WIPO_Copyright_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WIPO_Copyright_Treaty
- dragonwriter 12y ago> First of all those treaties took place before DMCA-1201 was passed. But they aren't self-executing, and, in any case, DMCA 1201 isn't -- despite being in part of the DMCA titled for various treaties that were implemented in that Title -- part of them in any case. DMCA (the whole thing, including 1201) was passed as normal legislation by the House and Senate and with the signature of the President. You can argue that that is undemocratic. > When they were kicked by normal democratic process, they turned to WIPO treaties which have no democratic oversight. Since any treaty, to be law in the US, requires ratification by the Senate, it is simply false to state that they have "no democratic oversight". But its irrelevant in this case, since DMCA 1201 is a provision of statute law adopted through the regular legislative process, not something that is binding law as a result of at treaty without implementing legislation adopted through the regular legislative process. > Then they turned back to the Congress and said: "you can't ignore your international obligations! Pass this law". A tactic which is not actually effective when Congress wants to ignore the "international obligation" at issue. At most, one could argue -- if the anticircumvention provisions were actually contained in any of the treaties that were being implemented in the DMCA, which they weren't -- that the treaties provided political cover for something Congress wanted to do. > That's not called a normal democratic process, it's called corruption and backdoor dealing. To the extent there was corruption or backdoor dealing involved, it wasn't WTO or WIPO treaties "passing" the provision. You can argue that the regular legislative process was subject to corruption or backdoor dealing -- such is not at all unheard of in US legislative processes -- but any treaty process is a sideshow to that in this case, since the provision didn't become US law by being included in a treaty, it became US law by being included in a regular bill passed through Congress and signed by the President.
- shmerl 12y agoSee my response here (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8840676 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8840676), it quotes the creator of DMCA himself who clearly states that he intended to bypass the democratic process. That's unquestionably corruption and a perfect example of undemocratically passed law. It also highlights how broken the current system is, when corrupted international treaties are used to shape the law bypassing normal democratic ways. > A tactic which is not actually effective when Congress wants to ignore the "international obligation" at issue. It should ignore it in theory, but in practice it doesn't have the guts and gives the power away to USTR and the like. That's what all this fast track idiocy is exactly about.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> See my response here (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8840676 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8840676), it quotes the creator of DMCA himself who clearly states that he intended to bypass the democratic process. How he describes his intent is irrelevant. The fact is that the law was passed through the House, Senate, and Presidents signature in exactly the manner laid out in the Constitution, not "by WTO treaty". And, while some of the law implemented things previously agreed to in WIPO and other treaties, the particular provision at issue -- Section 1201 -- did not. It might be undemocratic and/or corrupt, but if so the undemocratic/corrupt mechanism by which Section 1201 was passed is the normal US legislative process. > It should ignore it in theory It does in practice, when it is something that Congress doesn't want to do anyway -- this happens quite a lot on non-trade issues. > but in practice it doesn't have the guts and gives the power away to USTR and the like. More likely, on trade issues Congress takes advantage of treaties to provide for political cover for things Congress would like to do but where there might be greater political costs without that cover.
- shmerl 12y ago> How he describes his intent is irrelevant. The fact is that the law was passed through the House, Senate, and Presidents signature Using corrupt manipulation scheme and pressure by international trade agreements like described above. When democracy doesn't work, the fact that it's called democracy on paper is pretty meaningless. > It might be undemocratic and/or corrupt, but if so the undemocratic/corrupt mechanism by which Section 1201 was passed is the normal US legislative process. Yes, it is undemocratic and corrupt and it was passed through the legislative process, but as I said there was nothing normal about it. That process is not supposed to be manipulated by such treaties in such corrupt fashion, yet it is. Unless you simply mean that such level of corruption is generally a norm and this participial incident should be a default expectation of how Congress would function. It doesn't fit with what Lehman said that initially his attempts to pass these laws were rejected. I.e. he didn't manage to manipulate the Congress directly, and had to pull the weight of international agreement to change that. > It does in practice No it doesn't. Otherwise such stuff as fast track proposals to relinquish Congress oversight won't be even considered.