4 ms·
He has good arguments (except for one) but history has mostly shown that it's not wise to say something can never happen. Now for what I feel was one of his ba
by chaostheory 12y ago
He has good arguments (except for one) but history has mostly shown that it's not wise to say something can never happen.
Now for what I feel was one of his bad arguments:
"None of today's military aircraft are up to the job of intercepting it, and indeed, active radar can't even track it effectively—for that, you'd need something on the order of a cold war ballistic missile warning radar system, designed to provide advance notice of an ICBM strike."
In one sentence he outlines both the problem and the solution. Doesn't the west already have missile defense systems?
- CanSpice 12y agoSure, it does. But what happens when it goes wrong and the anti-missile missiles are launched against a sub-orbital passenger jet whose transponder has gone wonky?
- VBprogrammer 12y agoPeople die. Pretty much the same as what happens when an anti-aircraft weapon is used against an ordinary aircraft.
- chaostheory 12y agoPeople will die. Just like when more people died when cars didn't have safety belts and windshield wipers. Things will go wrong. We will fix them (eventually). When people list problems, I see temporary obstacles. Even mountains can be overcome: http://www.odditycentral.com/news/dashrath-manjhi-the-man-who-moved-a-mountain.html http://www.odditycentral.com/news/dashrath-manjhi-the-man-wh...
- alkonaut 12y agoDoes someone else find the interception argument pretty thin? If we are at some point in the future where we have commercial sub orbital flights, then you can bet your pants that military technology is a decade ahead at least. Why would it be intercepted by "today's military aircraft" when we are talking about a point in time that is clearly a few decades from now at least?