4 ms·
It is piratism, plain and simple. Calling it "abadonware" is just disingenuous whitewashing.
by zokier 12y ago
It is piratism, plain and simple. Calling it "abadonware" is just disingenuous whitewashing.
- cbd1984 12y agoI'm sure they're going to be very fast at removing things once the relevant copyright owners actually notice and send takedown demands. However, for all of the copyrighted material for which they never receive a notice, how is it immoral for them to host it? If nobody cares, nobody's receiving any money from their ownership of the copyright, so the hosting obviously can't be reducing their profits.
- joepie91_ 12y ago> If nobody cares, nobody's receiving any money from their ownership of the copyright, so the hosting obviously can't be reducing their profits. Well, realistically, that wasn't really the point of copyright to begin with anyway (increase/guarantee of profits). The point was a distribution/derivative monopoly for limited duration to allow a creator/inventor to recoup their investment. The whole profit thing is just a means to an end. If you look at copyright the way it was actually intended to work, it becomes very hard to argue that distributing abandonware should be prosecuted, no matter the circumstances.
- pmarin 12y agoIt is called preservation.
- joepie91_ 12y agoNice kneejerk response. Seriously though, no, it is not "whitewashing". It is a very specific term to describe a type of software that is considered obsoleted and 'abandoned' to the point that the rightsholder (if it is known at all) is virtually guaranteed not to make claims on it, simply because it's too old to be relevant. In the broader sense of the term, it is also used for software that has attained an unclear legal status because of some weird historical oddity that isn't handled by copyright law; many undocumented IP acquisitions, death of the entire family tree of the rightsholder, and so on. What you are describing, "piratism" (which, by the way, is the first time I see that particular spelling of "piracy") is what somebody supposedly does with it, not what it is. They describe two entirely different things. Not to mention that in some cases, distribution of abandonware can legitimately not fall under the banner of "piracy" due to one of the aforementioned edge cases.