3 ms·
There are a lot of basic mistakes. 1. Concorde was on the verge of being replaced by a more efficient Model B version, which was quieter and cheaper to run. Th
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
There are a lot of basic mistakes.
1. Concorde was on the verge of being replaced by a more efficient Model B version, which was quieter and cheaper to run. That was on the drawing board in the 1970s. Model C, D, E versions would have been cheaper and even more cost effective.
2. Concorde was actually killed by anticompetitive US politics. The story is too complex to detail here, but it's not a mystery in the aerospace biz.
3. If Stross thinks bizjets kill airliners, what's to stop the development of a hypersonic bizjet to give buyers the best of all possible worlds, and also provide the ultimate status symbol for those who care about such things?
4. Trrrrism? This part can be ignored, because the argument is silly.
5. Energy cost remains an issue. But if you're in the (literally) stratospheric biz set, you're not going to care about that.
6. Telepresence may kill some of the market, because I'm guessing 15 years from now it's going to be impressively immersive. But for some applications, including highly secure negotiations and ultra-speedy courier services, there's still no substitute for being there.
So in fact there's a perfectly viable, if innovative, business case, and the technology is looking at least potentially feasible.
I wouldn't be surprised to see these services running before 2030.
- cjcartlidge 12y ago"Concorde was actually killed by anticompetitive US politics." --> Any recommended reading for this?
- jacquesm 12y agoIt's not exactly a fact. In my view Concorde was killed by a 'perfect storm': changing market conditions, 9/11, that terrible crash in Paris. Together those three were what caused the towel to be thrown into the ring. Every time I visit Paris and I see it impaled on its stand it reminds me of a butterfly or something trying to escape. Such a sad image.
- masklinn 12y ago> It's not exactly a fact. Yeah, congress only banned SSTs and supersonic civilian flight right as concorde came online, that can't have had any impact on it.
- gaius 12y agoAlso see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8824444 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8824444 America has often used sly tactics to crush superior British technology.
- NickPollard 12y agoYeah, the lack of supersonic overfly on most countries (not just the USA) was one of the main factors against Concorde (despite the fact that in many cases the decibel levels were lower than cotemporaneous aircraft). It's no coincidence it's main routes (London->JFK, Paris ->JFK) are 90% over the Ocean. If you actually managed to get long distance hypersonic routes (such as London->Sydney, or even London->Beijing, London->Tokyo, etc.) at a significant time reduction, I can see it working.
- alistairSH 12y agoIn many ways, the Concorde was "dead" well before 9/11 or the Paris crash. Yes, those killed it for good, but costs, sonic booms (US landings were initially banned, then limited to JFK and Dulles), and politics killed the concept shortly after it was launched.
- ghaff 12y agoA few additional points. 1. re: First class dying. The reason is that, aside from some of the really high-end international options on e.g. Emirates, business class has effectively become first class. In general, today's business class accommodations are significantly better than first class in the old days with lie flat seats and personal entertainment systems. 2. Concorde was always pretty much a niche market. Saving a few hours in a comfortable first class seat is not a big win for just about anyone unless you're a high-priced lawyer doing an out and back to London for a day.
- notahacker 12y agoConcorde sold just 14 aircraft out of a production run of 20 with governments underwriting both the massive development losses and subsidising the two airlines that actually bought it. There's a good reason later models never made it off the drawing board. To put things into perspective, Bombardier have 243 net orders for the CSeries (an aircraft comparable in size if not capability) before the aircraft has been certified for commercial use. And the programme - involving comparatively simple technological innovation - isn't considered particularly commercially successful. Yes, the US government's decision to limit its ability to operate in US airspace didn't help Concorde. And neither did the equivalent Soviet airliner spectacularly exploding at an air show. Or rising fuel costs. But what reason does any madman with enough billions to get a hypothetical hypersonic aircraft built and certified for commercial operations have to think that the same won't happen again?