8 ms·
Why we're not going to see sub-orbital airliners
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sbate1987 12y agoI am reading Saturn's Children.. It makes so much more sense now that I know he is British.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoFaster flight times are like better fuel mileage. Once you reach a decent result, it's harder to justify more. With gas mileage, once I get about 35 miles per gallon, the cost of better exceeds any likely benefit. Once we can travel anywhere in about 24 hours or less, it's hard to justify the cost of better. In general, there is an economic optimum for most solutions. It's fuzzy because factors like comfort come into play. But it's there. It's a company's job to find it.
- finnh 12y ago> Once we can travel anywhere in about 24 hours or less, it's hard to justify the cost of better. Clearly you've never travelled with a two year old =) There are many cases where travel just isn't worth it, and the limiting factor is time rather than money.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoI do wish you were right, but I have had the joy of travel with small children. Grandchildren, too. As for the limiting factor being time, rather than money, Stross's article gives good examples of there not being enough people willing to pay the exorbitant costs.
- VLM 12y agoImagine a lighter than air cruise-ship. That's an interesting idea and somewhat more realistic from an engineering perspective. There must be some kind of happy medium of a giant lifting body full of helium that takes 24 hours but is large and luxurious. The key to all future transport seems to be turning it away from disciplined travel as the primary activity. Doesn't matter if its bizjets or cruise ships or trains or my crazy balloon idea. A cultural moving away from "travel for 4 hours strapped into a seat in a car or old fashioned airplance" but "hang out at the bar for 8 hours or play video games or post on facebook for 8 hours, or join the mile high club all night, oh, and at the same time as traveling from pt A to pt B but its not the primary activity"
- lxmorj 12y agoLondon -> Sydney takes 22 hours and requires at least one stop. Sub-ortibals will take ~3 hours, saving what amounts to an entire waking day. For an executive making just $10M per year, that's $27k worth of time. Add the cost of First Class or private flight, and the total value of a sub-orbital flight will easily be worth $40k for a larger-than-you-think-it-is subset of the population.
- khuey 12y agoAnd what the article points out (once you get through the OMG 911!!! crap) is that that's a very small target market. And scheduled commercial air travel generally doesn't serve tiny markets well because the demand is highly variable.
- nine_k 12y agoBusy routes, like NYC - London - Tokyo, will likely have enough traffic for a couple flights daily. The jet probably would not have to be as large as a Concorde was to be profitable.
- notahacker 12y agoIf it's a couple of flights daily then you're waiting up to 12 hours to get on one, and suddenly the time saving doesn't look so spectacular. Getting the size right is a problem I'm glad I don't have, but best not to make it too small or have too few flights bearing in mind your dollar development costs will be measured in 10s of billions.
- VLM 12y ago"larger-than-you-think-it-is subset of the population." There were about 18000 returns filed with the IRS above that AGI in 2010 according to some google searches. Honestly I don't think there's enough people in the world at that income level to develop and sell. Its also based heavily on the cultural assumption that nothing can be accomplished while traveling. Its not like they're being sedated and put into restraints for all 22 hours of that flight. Its fairly telling about the mentality of the board in general that the only use "we" can discuss for a "magic people mover" is a plaything for the ultra-rich. Because god only knows, they don't have enough favorable treatment over us mere proles, and they don't have enough other playthings to toy with. Kind of like the military industrial complex sycophants can't think of any reason for a vehicle to exist other than to drop a bomb from it or mount a gun on it. Some slightly more socially acceptable ideas for a passenger suborbital would be "extreme medivac" where no matter where you are on the planet if you get horrifically sick you're at the CDC isolation ward in 3 hours, "instant medical supply delivery" when you really really need a donor organ across the planet in 3 hours, and "extreme blue collar" like ship both a special factory floor machine tool part and a technician from the plant to install it because many factory floors cost far more than $40K/day if they're shut down.
- cryptoz 12y agoThe first reason is "because terrorism". It's difficult to keep reading, because the logic the author follows does not fit with the title or point the author's trying to make. This is a largely list of reasons why sub-orbital airliners aren't already common; it's got baseline assumptions that technology will not rapidly improve, that airports will not innovate, that passenger demand is static, etc. I don't understand the conclusion, given the points. It's a very pessimistic essay about the future, where all air travel is horrible and nobody will want to fly. I don't buy it.
- maxerickson 12y agoI disagree with your take. It says people will either take semi private jets or pay for more room on jumbo jets before they spend money going faster. It's posited that the private jet people derive greater convenience than they would get from going suborbital. The thing with rockets and jets and the like is that they aren't going to rapidly improve, they are fundamentally limited by chemistry and simple hydrocarbons are incredibly energy dense.
- Shivetya 12y agoI don't see the need for them regardless, as the their tech improves so will tech all areas. How much business travel is that require such service? Cannot many transactions be done via teleconferencing? Even product demos, physical interactivity requirements and such will be solved for remote customers long before hypersonic passenger planes. Then comes down to the other point, who does most of the traveling anyway? Those with the money and the time to do so. Hence why I would scoff as much at the LA to SF bullet trains as at hypersonic passenger planes. Neither will be cheap enough for the average person to just hop on and the average person probably doesn't have all that free time not already assigned out to use them. Getting somewhere faster is meaningless when you don't have the time to be there. As for the terrorism angle, until you remove the ability to pilot the vehicle on board it always a possibility, more hollywood than fact though
- mpeg 12y agoTelepresence technology is already pretty good, and I don't think it's going to replace in-person presentations. I spend most of my time in meetings or calls and there is always a certain awkwardness that comes with not being in the same room, people are a lot less warm and you lose the little interactions that make us relate to each other. On the other hand, I hate spending weeks in-between airports, and any kind of technology initiatives that improve long-distance travel sound great to me. There's definitely a market for this.
- lmm 12y agoThe same lobbying that makes bizjets exempt from the TSA will also mean that no-one will be bothered about fighter jets being unable to intercept these things. (Also, fighter jets didn't stop 9/11). Sub-orbital airliners, or at least sub-orbital exclusive bizjets, will happen for exactly the reason given towards the end of the article: because they will save rich people's time.
- raverbashing 12y agoThe article is risible to the point of ridiculousness You don't need a fighter jet to intercept it from the point it came from. It's that simple. "and indeed, active radar can't even track it effectively" Without providing any reason why, I doubt it. Oh I think it's using "active radar" as "secondary radar". Also primary radar can detect it. No problem. And airliners cross the ocean without much radar coverage TODAY, so there's that as well. Not to mention it can only fly at high speeds on high altitudes. You CAN'T come at Mach 5 or whatever and fly it on a building. Your plane will disintegrate first.
- transfire 12y agoThe primary problem is the cost of energy. Until we innovate away from an fossil-fuel based economy, then this mode of transportation will be accessible only to the very wealthy. It will probably require the invention of nuclear isomer batteries to make it affordable to the masses. As for sociopolitical factors, well it might not matter at all at the rate we're going. As soon as a suicide bomber gets hold of a nuke, it's pretty much all over. From then on martial law will be the rule of the land(s), and no one will be doing much of anything.
- Argorak 12y agoIn the same line of thinking: Plane travel got slower over the past years. http://slice.mit.edu/2014/03/19/airtravel/ http://slice.mit.edu/2014/03/19/airtravel/
- cjcartlidge 12y agoProfit, Profit, Profit.... It's sad that the 747-400 which was introduced in 1988 is still the fastest commercial aircraft currently. Aviation reminds me of the Formula 1 of the skies in its current rule set! (All about fuel saving)
- Argorak 12y agoI don't see the problem? There's just no one willing to pay the premium to fly at top speed. There were faster in that time, but they all went out of business.
- cjcartlidge 12y agoNo problem just a statement of fact. Goals in greater efficiently have never been as exciting as goals for greater speed (with disregard for efficiency).
- Argorak 12y agoAh, okay, excitement, I can agree with.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- fennecfoxen 12y agoAnd yet air travel is cheaper and more accessible to more people than ever. A faster plane doesn't do you much good if you can't afford the ticket.
- xenophonf 12y agoAs someone who travels for a living, the speed of the plane isn't that big of a deal. It's the fact that to get from North America to just about anywhere Africa, I have to detour through Europe, which is a complete waste of my time. I would much rather have better routes than faster planes. (For example, I could get to West Africa in ~12 hours from the east coast of the U.S. if the routes existed. That's a nice overnight flight, landing in the afternoon. I wouldn't have to waste a full day stuck in a plane, no new technology required.)
- marze 12y agoThe potential for terrorism is a problem that is easily solvable, especially when compared with the challenge of building a sub-orbital aircraft (which basically accelerates to almost orbital velocity before reentering as if from orbit). But the author's points about competition from subsonic high-end flights, as well as the potential for high fidelity video conference systems of the future to compete, are more compelling.
- jblow 12y agoYou can make a similar list about anything that doesn't exist yet. If it were easy, it probably would have been done. Eight years ago, you could have made an equivalent list about electric cars. Well, we have electric cars now and that situation is looking pretty good. Imagine you are an Elon-Musk-alike who wants to make fast air travel happen. Then this article isn't a list of why it's impossible, it is a list of problems you need to solve in order to make it work. I think we have enough examples in recent years to show that if someone with sufficient inventiveness attacks the problem hard, many of these kinds of things really are solvable.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoBut with sub-orbital hypersonic craft, you cannot get around the fact that they move very fast and thus carry a lot of kinetic energy and can deliver it before anyone can stop them. That's just how it works. You can't "advance" past that without a warp drive. I believe that the phrase is "functionally equivalent to a kinetic impact weapon". I think that Mr Stross has relaxed his thinking on sub-orbital hypersonic craft, i.e. he suggests that they might actually be allowed, but only if they come down far from a desirable location.
- jblow 12y agoLike I said, that is a problem. So start thinking about how to solve it .... Like, the plane is always landed from the ground, not the air. That idea introduces new problems, but you can start thinking about those too. Come on, people.
- ctdonath 12y agoAnd that "if" turns into a delay hugely chewing up the benefits of such high speed. There was, briefly, a rather grand project implementing a "fast ferry" between Toronto (Canada) to Rochester (New York). This cut the previously 3-hour drive around the intervening lake down to about 30-45 minutes, and included the luxury of enjoying the view/bar/games/social. Price wasn't bad (comparable to gas cost for the long trip), but certainly not trivial. Anyone coming to Rochester discovered "they come down far from a desirable location": having no personal transportation immediately available, it was upwards of an hour to take a bus from the port to downtown Rochester - turning an ~80% reduction in travel time to ~40%. The project was scrapped - twice[1] - after enormous expense. When throwing lots of money at diminishing returns, encroachments on those returns are very costly. [1] - There was huge political capital invested in the ferry's success. Upon completion, ridership was dismal and the project went bankrupt within a couple months and the boat went up for auction (few want such a specialized vessel). City-scale egos intervened and bought the boat back (!) at the auction, pressed it back into service. The mayor et al were promptly voted out of office, and the replacement sold the boat and permanently shut the project down.
- guelo 12y ago9/11 style terrorism was solved by reinforcing the cockpit doors. Everything else has been police state fear mongering.
- gaius 12y agoIt was solved as soon as ordinary passengers realized that hijackers didn't want hostages anymore. The cockpit door thing is security theatre too.
- gizmo686 12y agoThere was 1 coordinated attack where the hijackers did not want hostages. If I am a passenger on a hijacked plane, my guess would be that they are in it for the ransom.
- marssaxman 12y agoThen you are the problem. From now on airline passengers must simply assume that all terrorists are suicide bombers and act accordingly, fighting back with all available means; thus will we ensure that airline hijackings remain unviable.
- gizmo686 12y agoHaving a self destruct feature that automatically engages when an airplane is hijacked would also make make hijackings unviable. If you respond as if the hijackers are suicide bombers, when they really only want a ransom, then you risk some or all of the hostages getting injured or dyeing, as well as the potential for the plane, which would otherwise have landed safely, to crash into a populated area as the hijackers are distracted from piloting the plane, or the passenger may decide to be heroes and take over (crashing either deliberately or by accident).
- sandstrom 12y agoThis. It saddens me that 10+ years later the theatre is still running in every-single-airport around the world (admittedly in varying degree). http://www.terminalcornucopia.com/ http://www.terminalcornucopia.com/
- antoniuschan99 12y agoI agree. There are talks of a private supersonic aircraft. So logically sub orbital private fleet will exist. The rest always gets the bad end of the stick. But it will happen in a few generations. That and Mars.
- rdl 12y agoFor transpacific flights, first class (or business class, more often) is used by people who would otherwise be on business jets within the US. TBH, first class SQ Suites are nicer than any but the best business jets (I've never been on a really luxury jet like a 777 VIP, but I'd take SQ Suites over the G-II or Falcons I've been on). You're basically looking at $250k r/t SF-Beijing to take a Global Express or something. "Normal" business jets won't even get to Hawaii. I think things are different for transatlantic (esp if you're willing to stop somewhere like Canada or Ireland). Business jets make actual sense when you're doing a multi-stop itinerary, lots of last-minute changes, and flying into secondary and tertiary airports. They make a lot less sense for hub to hub intercontinental flights. You could solve all the security issues of intercepting a supersonic aircraft by having a failsafe override (optionally self-destruct). No need to build a Mach 5 interceptor when you can do it at c.
- falcor84 12y agoI don't know much about security failsafe overrides, but isn't that a bit like DRM? Would it be reasonable to expect the failsafe to remain unbroken, assuming that the adversary has physical access and has had time to plan?
- nihaody 12y agoThe real reason is the same as the reason for everything. Money. Is the value added by saving travelers X amount of hours worth Y amount of dollars? In this case Y seems prohibitively expensive so no. Same reason the Concorde failed.
- chaostheory 12y agoHe has good arguments (except for one) but history has mostly shown that it's not wise to say something can never happen. Now for what I feel was one of his bad arguments: "None of today's military aircraft are up to the job of intercepting it, and indeed, active radar can't even track it effectively—for that, you'd need something on the order of a cold war ballistic missile warning radar system, designed to provide advance notice of an ICBM strike." In one sentence he outlines both the problem and the solution. Doesn't the west already have missile defense systems?
- CanSpice 12y agoSure, it does. But what happens when it goes wrong and the anti-missile missiles are launched against a sub-orbital passenger jet whose transponder has gone wonky?
- VBprogrammer 12y agoPeople die. Pretty much the same as what happens when an anti-aircraft weapon is used against an ordinary aircraft.
- chaostheory 12y agoPeople will die. Just like when more people died when cars didn't have safety belts and windshield wipers. Things will go wrong. We will fix them (eventually). When people list problems, I see temporary obstacles. Even mountains can be overcome: http://www.odditycentral.com/news/dashrath-manjhi-the-man-who-moved-a-mountain.html http://www.odditycentral.com/news/dashrath-manjhi-the-man-wh...
- alkonaut 12y agoDoes someone else find the interception argument pretty thin? If we are at some point in the future where we have commercial sub orbital flights, then you can bet your pants that military technology is a decade ahead at least. Why would it be intercepted by "today's military aircraft" when we are talking about a point in time that is clearly a few decades from now at least?
- alkonaut 12y agoSo if security is as paranoid as it is today and the best fuel we can use to kick a plane half way into space is something similar to today's jet fuels then it won't happen? Basically "because 9/11 and concorde". Not sure what timescale the author considers and I agree it's unlikely within a few decades, but who knows what happens in 100 years?
- 32faction 12y agoHe makes good points but I've said it before and I'll say it again: sub orbital flights and non-interplanetary space travel in general is where the airline industry used to be which is a rough spot with a lot of known and unknown safety issues and expensive costs with inexpensive alternative but traditional methods. Today, I can buy a ticket for about the same price as dinner for two, maybe three. Back in the day say the 50s and 60s it was only the elite who could purchase a ticket because the rates were so expensive. Then, bus travel ala Greyhound was the way to go for long distance travel before commercial airlines really became more affordable. ADDENDUM: okay maybe a really nice dinner for two or three.
- corford 12y agoI used to work for an air charter company so know a bit about biz jets. Stross is missing an important point: there are only a handful of heavy jets that can fly non-stop from LHR to SYD. The Global Express (and variants), Dassault's 7X/8X and that's about it. They cost from $50 million up, can seat a maximum of 8 to 10 people and are impossible to charter "by the seat". They also require long runways, restricting which airports they can use compared to smaller biz jets. If something like the Sabre existed I can guarantee that high net-worth people in Europe/America with urgent business meetings (or a desire to maximise their holiday) in Australia would use it even if it meant needing to charter a helicopter to/from the space port to the centre of the city. Whether or not there would be enough demand to keep a regularly scheduled service going is another question. Stross is right when he says it's hard to see how it could compete with existing air transport options between shorter range locations (e.g. London - New York). Sabre (or similar) would have advantages for New York (or London) to Beijing though, so, who knows, in another 10 or 20 years maybe there will be enough demand for a few well chosen scheduled routes. In any case, I don't buy the terrorism angle at all. The problem will be (as is often the case in commercial aviation) finding and pricing route(s) to produce a viable passenger yield. Tricky if the only routes that make sense are long-haul ones with a high density of frequent first class business flyers (that's a pretty small pool).
- ctdonath 12y agoProposing hyper-scale projects can make a small group a tidy profit. Being on such a huge scale, early proposals & research can take years (not requiring a large team), and those interested in throwing enormous funds at the actual implementation think little of the relatively tiny funds (but still large for those working on it) for preliminary analysis. We may not see sub-orbital airliners for a long time, but those working on early analysis now can make a comfortable living on it.
- rationalthug 12y agoThe author's terrorism concerns are way overblown and the reasoning supporting them specious, but there is a more basic issue with hypersonic point-to-point transportation systems outside of the additional arguments related to current air travel, at least for vehicles designed to go suborbital/exoatmospheric: Once we are talking about traveling to a destination and not simply going "straight" up and down, the costs, maintenance issues, safety requirements, development time, thermal management, mission management, guidance systems, etc., get within spitting distance of actually developing an orbital vehicle. Future technology improvements and cost reductions cannot be ruled out, of course, but given the basic physics and what we know of the near future of aerospace technology, it seems a stretch (at least) to expect a profitable, safe point-to-point suborbital system to be a viable undertaking. And once we are talking about orbital systems, where the cost and risk/reward equation at least seem to be more desirable and unrelated to point-to-point travel, the question of suborbital point-to-point fades into the background.
- bashinator 12y agoI don't think Stross is actually saying that such terrorist attacks are feasible or likely - just that the culture of TSA and the slightest possibility of such acts will make inevitable the kind of security theater that's driving the wealthy away from regular first-class.
- DaniFong 12y agoThese cost assumptions are where the analysis falls down. Try to calculate what the cost of suborbital rocketry should be. There's a good case it should be even cheaper than today's jumbo jets.
- numair 12y agoI'm guessing the author is employing reverse psychology here? This article reads like an annoying lost of hyper-cynical arguments against hypersonic travel that any ambitious person would be eager to prove wrong. Sort of like the "we will never have small touchscreen-based mobile devices with the computing power of a desktop computer" argument I used to hear from extremely smart and experienced telecom execs around the time of the first iPhone rumors.