3 ms·
"I note however that the authors seemed to have forgotten about that rule just after writing it down..." I feel I need to remind you, and a lot of the other co
by jerf 12y ago
"I note however that the authors seemed to have forgotten about that rule just after writing it down..."
I feel I need to remind you, and a lot of the other commenters here, that this is a top-level summary of all the various arguments. And that it is possible on the Internet to mention arguments without actually advocating for them at the same time. I doubt you could find any individual on the planet that would "agree" with that entire document from top to bottom.
- simias 12y agoThen it should link to the various places where those arguments have been discussed. As it is it's hard to take that as a neutral reference and looks more like an opinion piece against the implementation of generics in Go trying to pass off as a neutral reference. If that was on wikipedia it would be littered with [citation needed].
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- scott_s 12y agoI get that, but I had the same reaction as simias. I, and I assume simias as well, is not concerned with the advocacy, but the lack of examples. I read the introduction and thought "Oh, cool! I'll get to see lots of use-cases showing how things behave in various circumstances." But I mostly saw the same hand-wavy arguments I see elsewhere. I think the better reaction to simias and my point is that this is clearly a work in progress. I assume that in the future, it will actually contain the use-cases I thought it would.