3 ms·
I kinda take issue with the "infinite growth is unsustainable" notion. If 1 dollar = 1 natural resource then clearly, yes, growth is constrained. But it isn't
by marcus_holmes 12y ago
I kinda take issue with the "infinite growth is unsustainable" notion.
If 1 dollar = 1 natural resource then clearly, yes, growth is constrained.
But it isn't. My example for this is clerical work. Banks (for example) used to employ vast rooms of clerks, who spent entire days performing simple, repetitive maths in double-entry ledgers to make sure the bank knew where all the money was. Now all of that is done by computers, and so cheaply that banks now offer massively increased services. More value, for less cost. That's growth.
Given that this is HN and frequented by legions of hackers trying to find problems to solve that create real value (by reducing costs or improving services), then this is the last place I'd expect the "growth is limited" mantra to be trotted out.
- furyofantares 12y agoUltimately, growth is limited by physical constraints, given our current understanding of physics. But it seems extremely premature to be worrying about this much unless you believe a singularity is right around the corner. And even then the idea of the singularity implies to me that we have no ability to predict what will happen - perhaps there are still enormous leaps to be made in physics that make our assumptions unfounded, or perhaps a greatly increased understanding of ourselves will eliminate our desire to continue to pursue growth indefinitely.
- collyw 12y agoDerivatives and complex financial products now mean that no one knows where the money is, and seems to be a big part of the financial crisis. Here in Europe the banks are offering almost no interest on savings as a result. Looks like the US is the same. >"Given that this is HN and frequented by legions of hackers trying to find problems to solve that create real value" Looking at the list of YCombinator funded startups on the front page (Reddit, Airbnb, Scribd), none of them seem to be tackling the big issues of climate change, pollution, seas being over-fished, deforestation, lack of physical resources for a growing population. Sure they increase efficiency in some small area, but I don't see any that even address environmental issues. You need to remember that the majority of the worlds population live on very little money, and don't have the comfy lifestyles that many of us in the west have.