4 ms·
Being an early employee is an incredibly bad deal. The first dozen people really should be equal partners, in writing.
by gaius 12y ago
Being an early employee is an incredibly bad deal. The first dozen people really should be equal partners, in writing.
- bigchewy 12y agoThen why would anybody start a company? why not just join as #12, once a ton of work has been done and you can anticipate, relative to when it was just an idea, the path of the company.
- jonnathanson 12y agoWe're speaking about expected values here. The expected value of joining a slightly de-risked startup as an early employee -- provided you don't get entirely screwed on equity, which is certainly a nontrivial risk -- is higher than the expected value of founding your own startup at T=0. This has a lot to do with things like risk, salary/equity mix, and the probability that your startup will actually succeed. Of course, the absolute value of a big win, should a win come along, is higher for the founder than for the early employee. But the early employee has more flexibility, and probably takes more swings at bat over the course of a given time period. He won't hit a homerun, but he may hit a series of doubles. The founder might hit a home run, or he might strike out. And on an unrelated note, the expected value of a stable job at a place like Google or Facebook is probably a lot higher than the expected value for either a startup founder or startup employee. This doesn't mean everyone should go BigCo and not mess around with startups. It just means people should figure out their personal risk-tolerance levels and ambitions, and act accordingly.
- byoung2 12y agoThe same reason people play the high stakes tables instead of penny slots...orders of magnitude more risk means orders of magnitude more reward.
- thirsteh 12y agoTo my understanding, being an early employee is the best deal because they still get substantial equity, but don't face nearly the same level of risk as the founders. Somebody did the numbers on HN a while back and showed that you have a higher probability of making it rich by being an early employee than by founding your own startup. I'm afraid I have no idea how to find that thread, though.
- byoung2 12y agoa higher probability of making it rich by being an early employee than by founding your own startup There are an order of magnitude more early employees than there are founders, so it makes sense...for every founder made rich, there are 10x as many early employees made rich.
- WalterSear 12y agoFWIW, the salary charts on angel list show the average startup equity offers there going for a bit more than a point. If your hypothetical startup sold for $100 million dollars, after dilution and taxes, you could expect maybe $500k. In other words, ~$125k extra for each year of a 4 year vesting period. That's nice, but it's certainly not substantial - it's about equal to the salary you'ld expect at the same jobs. And, we are talking about a hundred million dollar, moonshot exit - in other words, vastly, vastly more than most startups can expect to make. Most early employees make a modest, very decent, pittance.
- gaius 12y agoSubstantial, not really. After a year or two, the salary you give up in return for equity will probably be more than the founder's initial stake, yet you will get 1% of 1% of any upside.
- WalterSear 12y agoI wouldn't call it a bad deal as much as a reality check. If you are expecting fuck-you levels of equity as early stage employee, the vast majority of startup job openings will disappoint: IMHO, this says more about people's unrealistic expectations than the fairness of startup shares.