3 ms·
I am going to teach you something. It is important: please pay attention. Pull out one of your checks. Can you locate your name on it? Good. You'll see two
by patio11 17y ago
I am going to teach you something. It is important: please pay attention.
Pull out one of your checks. Can you locate your name on it? Good. You'll see two groups of numbers on the bottom of it. The first group of numbers, typically, is your ABA routing number. That tells me where you bank. The second number is your bank account number at that bank.
These three pieces of information are all I need to debit your bank account. There are a variety of ways to do it -- the simplest method is printing a "demand draft", which is essentially a check drawn against your account but printed on my printer. In place of signature it says "Authorized By Account Holder". (Signed, written, record!)
Every person who has ever held a check -- ANY CHECK -- from you in their hands, regardless of what is written on it, can debit your account at will. Every waiter, every grocery store clerk, every person involved in the processing chain.
Many people think checks are magically more secure than credit cards. Those people are not well acquainted with payment processing.
- stonemetal 17y ago>Many people think checks are magically more secure than credit cards. Yeah but they are not any less secure either. Buy something off amazon give them your credit card details number, expiration date, and security number off the back, and they can charge your credit card how much and whenever they want just the same as a check. Fraudulent activity (at least in the US ) has similar liability and penalty rules.
- billswift 17y ago>Fraudulent activity (at least in the US ) has similar liability Not hardly. Until you can collect from someone who rips off your checking account (good luck on that), YOU are liable for the amount (at least until your bank puts a stop payment on the account). With a credit card, you are liable only for the first $50, the card issuer is liable for anything over that.
- stonemetal 17y agoYour right it is better to use a check. In the event of a fraudulent check you are liable for $0, if you report it within 30 days of your statement same time period for credit cards. More than thirty days latter you split the responsibility with the bank, for credit cards it is your problem. The bank that cashed the check is on the hook for the funds in the case of check fraud.
- mjgoins 17y agoIncidentally, this is why Donald Knuth stopped sending people his famous checks for $2.56
- jhancock 17y agoYou are correct on the technical side. On the legal side, there is clear support to protect fraudulent use of a written check. If you go to your local police station and try to file a criminal report on someone abusing your Visa or PayPal account, your most likely going to get puzzled looks as to what to do. The laws are so strong that they have been co-opted in a seedy way to support the "payday check" industry. You write a post-dated check and if the money is not in the account by that date and the check bounces, the payday company uses your local sheriff's office to arrest you. This is a terrible abuse of public services but shows how strong the laws are.
- patio11 17y agoIf you go to your local police station and try to file a criminal report on someone abusing your Visa or PayPal account, your most likely going to get puzzled looks as to what to do. I'm looking for a piece of information in your profile like "I live in rural Afghanistan" which would make this crazy story sound plausible, but not finding it. If you live in a first world country like, e.g., the US, your local police department is quite familiar with the notion of credit card fraud. They'll tell you a) fill out this police report and b) bring it to the attention of your bank to get the charges reversed and c) the odds of us catching the guy are slim, which (they will not tell you) is the same as almost all financial crimes, including most fraudulent uses of checks.
- generalk 17y agoThere are similar laws for credit fraud, of course, so the stated benefit of "I don't have to give someone my details!" is confusing. In any kind of "pull" system where I have to give someone else credentials to access my account, there's going to be the potential for fraud. A "push" system, where you have the ability to deposit into an account but not withdraw from it, sounds much more secure.
- jhancock 17y agoI agree, the stated benefit of I don't have to give my details, is not just confusing but plain wrong. Checks leak as much if not more information. I was replying the parent post of why checks do have some value. The laws for check fraud are different than credit fraud and the like. In most cases (each U.S. state is different), check fraud laws are old and quite strict. These laws have statutory obligations to fulfill to enable criminal prosecution. These requirements in turn force law enforcement and banks to take action. This may not always happen, but there is a framework for pushing it to happen.
- SamAtt 17y ago"Every person who has ever held a check -- ANY CHECK -- from you in their hands, regardless of what is written on it, can debit your account at will. Every waiter, every grocery store clerk, every person involved in the processing chain." And what's to stop every person who has ever held your Credit Card from doing the same? Thankfully many institutions are now asking for a zip code when you use a credit card online but most still don't and that means every waiter, grocery store clerk, etc... who has held your credit card long enough to write down the number could use it to go on a shopping spree.
- btilly 17y agoThis varies by country, but in the USA by law your maximum possible financial loss from this is $50. The credit card issuer is liable, and that is why they put energy into fraud detection systems. By contrast the immediate damage to you from misuse of your check information is much worse.