4 ms·
> However, I've always failed to see the practical interest of categories. It's nice to see how various things can be described or defined in a categorical fram
by JadeNB 12y ago
> However, I've always failed to see the practical interest of categories. It's nice to see how various things can be described or defined in a categorical framework. It may shade new light on some concepts, but I didn't see any useful theorems you could apply (like in vector spaces for instance). Probably I didn't go deep enough.
Almost by definition, you can't see the point of category theory until you go deep enough. Because statements in category theory are, in a very profound sense, statements about everything, they must logically be less substantial (or at least no more substantial) than statements about any particular thing.
If that is so, then why bother making these less substantial statements? The point is precisely that they do apply to everything, so that your knowledge about categorical statements pertaining to vector spaces instantly translates to knowledge of exactly the same statements about groups, or modules, or … whatever (as long as the relevant categories satisfy the same hypotheses).
That is, from my point of view at least, the utility of category theory is almost never in what it has to say about any one discipline, but rather the connections it makes, or at least the 'automated transfer of knowledge' that it allows.
EDIT: Also, I think that, much like the monad tutorial profusion, the large number of resources for learning category theory makes people think that they are obligated to go out and find a use for it. I think one is much less likely to be successful with the mindset "where can I use category theory?", and much more likely to be successful with the mindset "I have this language in my lexicon, and so will recognise the opportunity to speak it when it arises."
- tel 12y ago> "I have this language in my lexicon, and so will recognise the opportunity to speak it when it arises." Oh, I like that a lot! It's a great way the value of both "getting" CT and "getting" monads.