3 ms·
I waited a while to post this, because I wanted to see if anyone felt the same. It seems I'm alone - which is both interesting and a little scary! To me it see
by javajosh 12y ago
I waited a while to post this, because I wanted to see if anyone felt the same. It seems I'm alone - which is both interesting and a little scary!
To me it seems to me like Stallman has become a professional complainer about how programs are made and distributed, and critically, his position is weakened by not being a working practitioner.
I'd be ashamed at fumbling with the presentation software; here you are making a case for free software, and end up making a really good case against it (does anyone want to use software that befuddles an expert programmer?) I also feel that it reflects poorly on Stallman himself that he immediately throws up his hands and says "I don't know how to do this" instead of carefully examining the situation. (Of course, there's also a case to be made that that was a very mature and wise move.)
Here's the real problem. Take the market of custom software for small business. Can this be done in a free software model? I think yes, but only if you could get clients to agree to a) pay for custom software development, and b) give all of that custom development away to their competitors. One can imagine the ultimate SaaS platform (including perfect freedom to self-host, etc), open source, all modifications (hosted and otherwise) dutifully shared. Question: would such a thing be good or evil?
P.S. Out of curiosity, since he doesn't seem to program anymore, and I can't see how complaining could pay well, does anyone know how he actually pays the bills?
- MrBuddyCasino 12y agoNo you are not alone, but since people often simply just downvote instead of discussing dissenting views, which takes more time, there is a risk to express minority opinions in certain threads, as it will drain your precious karma. To half-answer your question: RMS once got 150,000 shares of VA Linux which were worth millions at some time, but I have no idea if he ever sold them before they became worhtless. He lives mainly from his speaking engagements nowadays. And in case you will ever want to have him speak at your event, this what you are signing up for: https://groups.google.com/a/mysociety.org/forum/#!msg/mysociety-community/zkyZpOXjgoQ/_8xyXSxv9zYJ https://groups.google.com/a/mysociety.org/forum/#!msg/mysoci... That line from War Games, you are going to need it: "Remember you told me to tell you when you were acting rudely and insensitively? Remember that? You're doing it right now."
- javajosh 12y agoThanks for the link; it doesn't help my impression of him, but I wouldn't use it for an ad hominem either. Being weird and demanding doesn't necessarily correlate with being wrong. "Not being able to do stuff" does, though.
- MrBuddyCasino 12y agoYes, he got shit done - this is huge, and trumps most other arguments you might make. Still I wonder about an alternate reality where the OSS movement had a leader that was less of a nut-job.