4 ms·
Mozilla Persona was the best of the authentication protocols :(
by StavrosK 12y ago
Mozilla Persona was the best of the authentication protocols :(
- ldng 12y agoWell, it still could be, no ? If someone would put the resources behind that is.
- StavrosK 12y agoSure, protocols only die when nobody uses them, but who will?
- onli 12y agoI would. Depending on what you are working on, you can use it how it is right now. It's nicely integrated into gmail, it works good enough for other mail providers. There are modules for probably every big web programming language and for many frameworks, most blogsoftware should have a plugin for it. I use it in all my personal projects and had no issue with persona itself. The one issue was that the sinatra gem is unmaintained, but there is a fork that works fine.
- StavrosK 12y agoSure, I do too, but I'm talking about a big-name mail provider, like Google or yahoo. The bridge is good enough for support, but not for mindshare.
- zanny 12y agoYou should. Not necessarily you, but a lot of startups are on here and they all should be pushing persona logins. It works, its available, go get it If enough sites adopt it it puts pressure on both Google and Mozilla to implement it as a browser feature the way it was designed to be. Then we have personal logins without information jacking or the potential for tolls on logins.
- brunoqc 12y agoHow was it the best?
- StavrosK 12y agoThe sibling explains it well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8831465 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8831465
- nickbauman 12y agoMozilla Persona _should_ have been the successor to OpenID. It solves almost all of the problems with OpenID, which were: 1) The NASCAR problem. Arrive at a page for a site you signed up for with OpenID and be totes confused: which "openId" did I use for this site? 2) The privacy leak: If you used your Google OpenID, now Google knows that you logged into someotherplace.com with your "openid" 3) The ID problem. Wait, what? Yeah, like, how does someone keep track of which "openid" ID is "me". The final problem is that not many people will write a full implementation of it other than the big players like mozilla itself or Google or Microsoft. And the latter two don't have a ton of incentive to do so.
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoThe final problem is that not many people will write a full implementation of it other than the big players like mozilla itself or Google or Microsoft. And the latter two don't have a ton of incentive to do so. When I see such a proliferation (I looked at one architecture image of OpenID.connect and was shocked) than I am reminded of SOAP and I again think, that one reason might be, to hold smaller players at bay -- and to give the bigger players an advantage. For Facebook, Amazon or an other big internet company, it is really easy to even implement a big stack of software with complicated architectures and many features -- but for a four people start-up it is a big problem.
- vertex-four 12y agoHonestly, if you already have a working OAuth2 server implementation, adding OpenID Connect support to it is not difficult. For oauth2-server-php, the OpenID Connect extension is a few hundred lines. On the client side, there's a glut of OpenID Connect implementations for various languages, or you could outsource it to the likes of mod_auth_openidc for Apache, or a node.js proxy using Passport, or whatever you'd like. Once a user is authenticated, which can be handled by the libraries just fine, the rest of the data model is simply OAuth2 and a key/value list of claims about the user. I'm not sure how anything is pushing smaller players out, so long as those players are willing to use MIT (or equivalent) licensed code?
- 12y ago
- seanieb 12y agoUntil Mozilla gets Two Factor Auth they should NOT be doing anything with passwords or authentication.
- StavrosK 12y agoWhat does 2FA have to do with Persona? Your comment is just uninformed and wrong.
- nickbauman 12y agoPersona ameliorates the need for two-factor auth because you have to have control over an email account registered as the provider for Persona to interact with the user. Logic being if someone controls your email account already, it doesn't matter that you have two-factor auth, they can shut it off because they control your account. A lot people using two factor auth with their Google account have been hacked exactly this way.
- ta76767 12y ago> Logic being if someone controls your email account already, it doesn't matter that you have two-factor auth, they can shut it off because they control your account. A lot people using two factor auth with their Google account have been hacked exactly this way. Can you explain this a little more? I don't think I understand, because to me it sounds like you're saying, "once your account is hacked, two factor authentication won't help because your account has been hacked, so the adversary can disable two factor authentication". Don't major changes to accounts like that sometimes require re-authenticating with all required factors? I need to do this if I want to add a bill pay recipient to my bank account even if I'm already logged in.
- nickbauman 12y agoSocial engineering is the most common cause of account hijacking with two-factor. Check this out: they used his cell phone provider to get at his google account. http://www.makeuseof.com/tag/two-factor-authentication-hacked-shouldnt-panic/ http://www.makeuseof.com/tag/two-factor-authentication-hacke...