3 ms·
I don't think class is defined solely in terms of income is it? Isn't class more about background, education, politics, lifestyle, tastes and culture? You can b
by chrisseaton 12y ago
I don't think class is defined solely in terms of income is it? Isn't class more about background, education, politics, lifestyle, tastes and culture? You can be poor but upper class, and you can be a millionaire but working class.
- Retric 12y agoIn the US class is defined by either income or capital and nothing else.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoClass is about whether or not you own all the tools necessary to produce a useful product and send it to market. If you own the means of production, you're a capitalist. If you must hire yourself out because you don't own the means of production, you're working-class.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoWhat's a "useful product"? Who owns the means of production? The CxOs? The board? The product design team? The shareholders? You can be low-income and still be a shareholder of a publicly listed company - the broker I use here in Australia has a minimum trade of AU$500 with AU$19.95 brokerage fee. What class do I fall in to if my income is below average yet I have significant stock holdings? Anyone with a computer, an Internet connection, and the gumption to do so, can send a product to market.
- eli_gottlieb 12y ago>Who owns the means of production? The shareholders and board, primarily. >What class do I fall in to if my income is below average yet I have significant stock holdings? Well, you're implying that you have to work for a living or starve, so you're working-class. >Anyone with a computer, an Internet connection, and the gumption to do so, can send a product to market. And yet only roughly 0.1% of the population actually lives off anything other than wages.