7 ms·
How Can an Aircraft Disappear Over the Ocean?
- gol706 12y agoI don't know how may aircraft are flying over these areas of open ocean at a given time, but could some sort of mesh network be created? Or perhaps ADS-B receivers could be placed on buoys like the ones used for tsunami detection?
- aosmith 12y agoFor anyone interested in ADS-B you can dump information from nearby aircraft with a DTV stick and dump1090: https://github.com/antirez/dump1090 https://github.com/antirez/dump1090
- wglb 12y agoI use this and it is a lot of fun. However, to do well, you need an outside antenna with good view of horizon. Edit: And this is more fun: http://www.flightradar24.com/free-ads-b-equipment http://www.flightradar24.com/free-ads-b-equipment
- bartwe 12y agogps+iridium uplink ?
- perlgeek 12y ago... and the iridium uplink, which is presumably expensive, only as a fall-back if normal HF communication is available.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- laxatives 12y agoExpensive relative to what? The consumer grade iridium device is only ~$1000.
- mikeash 12y agoPer-minute or per-byte charges are also really high. But that's "high" relative to individuals, maybe not compared to operating an airliner.
- achamayou 12y agoSomething like 3USD/min it looks like. At GSM's 13 kbit/s, that's ~0.4cent/kbit. It doesn't sound like a significant cost to report a position regularly at that rate, not compared with the cost of flying an airliner anyway.
- laxatives 12y agoI'm not sure about the details of the plan, but iridium offers unlimited data for something like ~$100/month. I'm sure bandwidth is terrible, but again, these costs are small, even for individuals.
- mikeash 12y agoThat's impressive! I severely overestimated the current cost of the service. Here's a page with good info for the curious: http://www.groundcontrol.com/Iridium_Go.htm http://www.groundcontrol.com/Iridium_Go.htm
- joshgel 12y ago"instead, air navigation service providers like the FAA would pay to use" these new tools. Seems like an appropriate government objective, but instead of just doing it themselves, govt will end up overpaying some private company with the right connections.
- peteratt 12y agoIt blows my mind that I can turn on my phone, go to some mapping app and get more accurate and frequent position updates than a commercial airplane. It's just absurd.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wglb 12y agoCertainly. However, if you are here https://www.google.com/maps/place/Mariana+Trench+National+Wildlife+Refuge/@22.4343755,146.2035517,21z/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0x66d68f4a4dae6b63:0xa347087314d7e066 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Mariana+Trench+National+Wi... how would you communicate that to the rest of the world? That is the harder part.
- jarek 12y agoWith GPS, the hard part isn't figuring out where you are, it's telling the rest of the world where you are.
- UhUhUhUh 12y agoA lat/long position is about 50 bits. Talk about serious bandwidth...
- wglb 12y agoRight. And if they don't hear you or you don't hear them, any non-zero bandwidth is a non-contact.
- sambeau 12y agoOceans are huge. Where do you send those 50 bits if you are 1000s of miles from anywhere?
- jordanthoms 12y agoSatellite. The so-called cost concerns are just stupid, if I can afford a satellite phone airlines can afford to report 50 bits to satellite every 30 seconds.
- symmetricsaurus 12y agoWhy not create a mesh network using the planes themselves. Surely most planes must be in line of sight with several other planes even over the ocean. That way they could broadcast their position among other things.
- thebenedict 12y agoIt sounds like ADS-B can do that: "It does, however, have an air-to-air capability designed for use in environments like the ocean that allows aircraft to “see” each other—the FAA is now trying out this technique." Sounds like it could work in much of the US and Europe, but planes are more sparse in other parts of the world. Africa for example has minimal ADS-B coverage and a relatively small number of planes in the air at once: https://flightaware.com/adsb/coverage https://flightaware.com/adsb/coverage
- lucaspiller 12y agoI think the author is a bit confused by how this technology works. My understanding is that an aircraft can also have an ADS-B receiver onboard, which allows the pilot to identify other traffic in the local area - it doesn't rebroadcast the signals as in a mesh network (I don't think there is any encryption in these signals either, so that's probably a good thing). ADS-B is only really used currently as a secondary resource for identifying aircraft rather than seeing where aircraft are. The primary way is by using a radar return, and matching this up with the aircraft transponder which reports the aircraft ID and altitude. At the moment I don't think there are any hard requirements on having ADS-B transmission equipment on aircraft, although most commercial airliners already have it (which is what FlightAware and such usually use - at least outside the US). It will become a requirement over the next few years however for most civilian aircraft.
- optimusclimb 12y agoThat article used the word "expensive" many times, but I really have no idea what that translates to. What could be more expensive than losing a few hundred lives and an aircraft? Does the tech used in PLBs such as the spot messenger not work over the ocean?
- dzhiurgis 12y agoThey do. That's what they are intended for. They even make lifejackets with then nowadays. Pathetic. Edit: did not see parent mentioned SPOT messenger. These have reduced coverage, as they are not emergency beacons.
- mikeash 12y agoNote that SPOT coverage is not worldwide, and it won't work in some parts of the world, both ocean and land: http://www.findmespot.com/en/index.php?cid=108 http://www.findmespot.com/en/index.php?cid=108 It is quite good though, and would have worked for the mysterious Malaysia disappearance as well as the recent one. I'm sure other systems exist with better coverage and higher prices.
- dzhiurgis 12y agoIs that same as EPIRB run on Cospas-Sarsat programme? The coverage looks quite similar http://www.marsat.ru/coverage%20maps/GAN_coverage_I3.gif http://www.marsat.ru/coverage%20maps/GAN_coverage_I3.gif
- mikeash 12y agoIt seems that the underlying service is run by Globalstar: http://www.globalstar.com/en/index.php?cid=106&sidenav=232 http://www.globalstar.com/en/index.php?cid=106&sidenav=232 It looks like Cospas-Sarsat is for emergency use only, while SPOT is used both for emergency location and for routine tracking.
- jdhawk 12y agoYou have to have Boeing/Airbus approved hardware, which will come from one of the big boys in Aero Electronics (Garmin/Honeywell...) and cost megabucks due to all the redundancy, testing, engineering. You have to have it approved by the airline, which requires all kinds of testing and red tape. You have to take the airplane out of service in order to install it, and train tech's to maintain and diagnose it, which means updated documentation. You have to train pilots on its functions, and how to use it properly, and all the implications of a malfunction in the hardware. Cost != airtime + cheap PCBS slapped in a dome on top of the airframe.
- davidlumley 12y agoWhy is there no information about the Inmarsat and Iridium networks that a lot of aircraft already use? ADS-B is fantastic for fast, accurate position data, and apart from the hardware is essentially 'free' for an aircraft to make use of. Satellite transceivers are also relatively cheap (a few thousand dollars), but the main expense is in sending data to and from the transceiver. This cost can be alleviated by having the transceiver programmed to send a position report from every 30 seconds to every few minutes. It's also possible to switch between ADS-B, and satellite networks when in range of ADS-B ground stations to make things more efficient. Satellite tracking fairly ubiquitous in Australia, New Zealand, the UK, and the US – there's even some consumer level products such as SpiderTracks [ http://www.spidertracks.com/collections/hardware/products/hardware-spider-s5 http://www.spidertracks.com/collections/hardware/products/ha... ] which provide similar SBD modems (Iridium network) to those used in commercial aviation. I'm guessing it's just not a requirement for aircraft operating in that airspace to use satellite tracking, as there was even less data about Malaysia Airlines flight MH 370. Source: Worked at a company that provided both hardware and a web based application to commercial airlines to track their fleets.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoIridiums is rolling out new satellites that have ADS-B receivers on board (for open ocean data collection), and will be providing this data to the FAA for a fee. Its a solved problem, but will take time to roll out. http://www.aireon.com/AboutAireon/AnIridiumInnovation http://www.aireon.com/AboutAireon/AnIridiumInnovation
- fragmede 12y agoWhat's more, here's a product that's already on the market, and has clear pricing terms: https://www.ybtracking.com/products-yb3 https://www.ybtracking.com/products-yb3 The device is ~$600, and to have a 13 hour flight transmit a GPS signal every 5 seconds would cost another $600 per-flight - I'm sure the airlines could negotiate a better deal. Also note that they are currently available for purchase.
- fixedd 12y agoYou can't just slap any old device into an aircraft and call it done. There's huge amounts of money + time that must be invested to get it certified, and it has to be done for each aircraft type. I haven't looked it up, but I'd wager an Iridium transmitter for transport aircraft would be in the 10s of thousands of dollars, minimum.
- ikeboy 12y agoDoes anyone have a good breakdown for the claims I've seen elsewhere that tracking every plane would cost billions?