3 ms·
I don't understand why the author of this piece describes granting new work visas as offering employers an "exemption from supply and demand (of labor)". I wou
by schoen 12y ago
I don't understand why the author of this piece describes granting new work visas as offering employers an "exemption from supply and demand (of labor)". I would view it as exactly the opposite -- I see requiring visas for employees in the first place as the "exemption from supply and demand (of labor)".
I guess this is a pretty deep disconnect. Some people see the normal or basic state of affairs as one in which any employer can hire any employee in the world, and then governments alter this background situation for political and cultural reasons by choosing to prevent some migration and employment offers (thereby artificially depressing the supply of labor in their territory and the demand for labor in other territories). Other people see the normal or basic state of affairs as one in which people can only seek employment in their own countries of origin; then governments alter this background situation for political and economic reasons by choosing to permit some migration and employment offers (thereby artificially increasing the supply of labor in their territory and the demand for labor in other territories).
On one view, granting work visas is undoing a very small part of a very large prior government intervention in the economy; on the other view, it's creating a new intervention where none existed before. On one view, the baseline is a single world market for labor which then gets distorted by migration restrictions; on the other, the baseline is hundreds of largely isolated national markets for labor which then get distorted by importing foreigners.
- skylan_q 12y agoI see requiring visas for employees in the first place as the "exemption from supply and demand (of labor)". National boundaries, timezones, cultures, local governance issues, political issues, etc... still exist. The globalist view is ignores this and assumes that visas are an artificial barrier to entry. If the argument is to promote US interests, (as his is, and PG's possibly is) one can't view it through globalist glasses but nationalist glasses. Large corporations seek to increase their ability to get labor in whichever country their operations reside. This increases the supply of labor in that country, which drives downward pressure on wages.
- foobarqux 12y agoPromoting US interests rarely means promoting interests of the US middle class.
- glesica 12y agoYou make an excellent point. Thank you for pointing this out, it seems like a very simple difference in point of view, but I had never though of it quite like this before. I do think there is an additional factor at work, though, and that is the fact that efforts to open up the world market have tended to be guided by the capitalist class. It is easy to import from, or export to, another country, but very difficult to relocate abroad as a worker (and I am saying this as an American currently living abroad). So goods and capital have been allowed to move, quite easily, between countries through "free trade" agreements, but labor is still "stuck". So, from an American standpoint, I can see why people are grumpy about the H1B issue, because, once again, the primary group that will benefit from this "liberalization" of trade is the capitalist class. So whether you regard immigration restrictions as an interference in the market, or a natural state of the world, their loosening has been done in a way that primarily benefits a single, small group of people, so of course everyone else is up-in-arms.
- blfr 12y agoSome people see the normal or basic state of affairs as one in which any employer can hire any employee in the world ... Other people see the normal or basic state of affairs as one in which people can only seek employment in their own countries of origin No. Most people simply compare plans for change with the status quo, with what actually is. And to me, that seems like the most reasonable starting point.
- scarmig 12y agoIt's a simple empirical question. Well, strike simple... Whether something is part of the same supply--or demand--depends essentially on how fungible the goods/labors in question are. Let's say you have two similarly skilled groups of rockstar ninja programmers on two isolated planets. No matter the groups' similarity, it'd be silly to consider them part of the same supply. The way to establish this empirically would be to clone a group of identical programmers on Kepler 62e and see if that influences labor prices on Sol 3. If it doesn't, they're not part of the same supply. Which is what economics predicts you'd see, since there's no way for employers on one planet and programmers on the other to interact. Now consider the Bay Area market. If you doubled the number of programmers here while maintaining a consistent composition of skills, you'd probably see compensation drop. Which brings us to, do programmers form a global supply source and do employers for them form a global demand source? And the answer is... jein, though on the whole there does seem to be distinct national and regional markets, coupled together with various levels of porosity. Of course, the obvious complaint is that our policy choices--restrictionist immigration regimes--have created the markets we work in. And that's a fair complaint! And that's always the most vexing thing about economics. There's no natural order of things that we can lean on to push naturalistic fallacies. Things are what they are. If they changed, things would be different.
- dantheman 12y agoUntil very recently, in human terms, the view of the "any employer can hire any employee in the world" was the default and only view.
- Retric 12y agoEffectively any employer can higher any employee anywhere in the world (excluding sanctions), that does not mean they get to immigrate automatically. And any suggestion that we remove all immigration restrictions are going to get stiff responses from the vast majority of people in most countries.