15 ms·
Are the workers powerless in this? I am not debating the premise, but it's a fair question. Wages are generally driven by market conditions (except in Union job
by briandear 12y ago
Are the workers powerless in this? I am not debating the premise, but it's a fair question. Wages are generally driven by market conditions (except in Union jobs, but that's another discussion..) so I wonder if the similar competition for wages ought not include hours worked. A 40 hour job paying 50k would be preferable to a 60 hour job paying 60k, yet most job seekers simply look at the salary and not the cost. It would seem that wage competition should naturally extend to hours competition. I see this in some startups.. They might offer you $125k yet imply an 80 hour week is expected. So that salary is dramatically lower than a 100k position at 40 hours. Yet that differential is rarely discussed. I think a mandatory, government imposed rule ultimately distorts the market. What if someone is willing to work extra hours as a part of their salary? I'm not sure the government 'protecting' us can actually be quantified so clearly. If an average position pays $55k and requires 55 hours, then with new overtime rules, there's nothing preventing that salary to become $40k. My point is that business will always optimize -- a business will never pay more than the value of the input. What would likely happen is either increased hiring of no benefits part timers or an increase in the product price which would then drive inflation. There's some serious unintended consequences that the original author seems to gloss over. I am not sure who this guy is but unless he's paying his workers overtime, then I don't much care what he has to say. If he's a "wealthy" entrepreneur who doesn't like the rules, he's free to pay his workers more. He's also making the suggestion that "corporate" profits have grown-- which corporations? All of them? The majority of businesses are small businesses -- what effect would these rules have on them?
I am not dismissing the premise, just suggesting that there is far more complexity and shades of gray involved.
- markbnj 12y agoYou can't really negotiate on expected working hours, because the minute that comes up you will be off the list of prospects at most places. Salary is out there in the open and can be talked about, but the idea that you might not want to work 50 hours? Not so much.
- alkonaut 12y agoI'm not working in the US but I'd definitely not take a job at any salary without knowing the office culture, overtime trends etc. I'd simply be very up front with that I'm not about to work more than 40h on average, and that the compensation is exactly for that. When I recruit people, I fully expect them to have the same idea. If this makes me less eligible for the position then that's all the better: I wasn't interested anyway.