4 ms·
Tolkien's work can be naive and problematic on matters of race, but it's a mistake to think that he himself was racist. He was furiously opposed to the Nazis we
by PhasmaFelis 12y ago
Tolkien's work can be naive and problematic on matters of race, but it's a mistake to think that he himself was racist. He was furiously opposed to the Nazis well before it was fashionable to be so, and the same with apartheid.
Describing LotR as good white northern people vs. evil black southern people is extremely inaccurate, I think. Some of Sauron's minions were dark men from the South, but see Sam's reaction when he finds one of them dead: "He wondered what the man's name was and where he came from; and if he was really evil at heart, or what lies or threats had led him on the long march from his home; and if he would not really rather have stayed there in peace."
The unshakably evil nature of the orcs is certainly problematic, and it's fair to say that Tolkien wasn't conscious of the implications there; but it's also fair to say that orcs are created things without free will, and Tolkien thought of them more like self-replicating war machines than like people of any earthly race. Humans (and elves and dwarves and hobbits) of whatever color are invariably shown as being moral beings with the capacity for both good and evil.
- wpietri 12y agoI'd happily believe that he wasn't consciously racist. But I'd find it hard to believe he had no racial bias; even today things like Project Implicit show most people as biased, and he grew up in a very different era. But still, I think the way he exaggerates various human race and class characteristics into Essentially Different Peoples and then puts together a giant race war is problematic as anything other than light entertainment. Great battles of Good vs Evil are fine for kids' stories and escapist fantasy, but I think Moorcock and others are spot on that it's troubling to the extent that people take it more seriously.