source code should also be included as a matter of course... i don't think it is an oversell, in the sense that it is still unusual to include source code and

source code should also be included as a matter of course... i don't think it is an oversell, in the sense that it is still unusual to include source code and experimental setups [at least in my field]. a replicable environment with included source code is a large step forward. sad as that might be.