3 ms·
> What I find intriguing is that if you assume that everything is based on cause and effect, then (I think) you necessarily run into an infinite regress problem
by JadeNB 12y ago
> What I find intriguing is that if you assume that everything is based on cause and effect, then (I think) you necessarily run into an infinite regress problem (the cause of a cause of a cause …) unless you define some "uncaused cause", or the concept of causation breaks down at some point.
Another possible resolution is a cyclic picture (something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyclic_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyclic_model), in which the cause of the cause of the cause of … may be the original event.
- rndn 12y agoIsn’t that an infinite regress problem?
- JadeNB 12y ago> Isn’t that an infinite regress problem? I can certainly see the sense in which it might be said to be, but I think that's not the sense in which the term is originally meant. I tried to come up with an explanation of why I think they were meaningfully different by an appeal to mathematical analogy, but I'm not sure that it's convincing. Fermat argued as follows: a positive integer solution to `x^4 + y^4 = z^4` could always be converted into a smaller such solution, and you can't produce ever-smaller positive integers forever, so there weren't any such solutions in the first place. I'd say that this is clearly an infinite regress (though it was actually called infinite descent). On the other hand, consider the problem of subtracting 1. In the system of ordinary (not-necessarily-positive) integers, this leads to a (non-paradoxical) infinite regress; whereas, in the system of integers modulo some fixed positive integer, it leads to a (non-paradoxical) circularity (where repeatedly subtracting 1 from a number will eventually yield that number itself). I think that it is reasonable to call these different phenomena.
- hasenj 12y agoCyclic causality is even more troublesome than infinite regress. I find myself leaning towards causation breaking down at some point. Just like our concepts of "position" and "momentum" break down at the quantum level.
- noobermin 12y agoYou say that causa sui or at least cyclic cause is troublesome without saying why. I'm curious for your reasoning.