3 ms·
HN doesn't need a dup detector - it has that, humans. It needs a better policy/idea of what to do about dups. My suggestion: Merge the comments, have a mod p
by ars 17y ago
HN doesn't need a dup detector - it has that, humans.
It needs a better policy/idea of what to do about dups.
My suggestion:
Merge the comments, have a mod pick a title and url for the main view. Show the other/alternate titles and urls on the comments view.
The mod ranking is whichever is higher, and any future mods get credited to all submitters.
Have a flag called dup, which asks you for the id (or url) of the dup, and notifies a mod.
- chanux 17y agoI see your point. But still there are times that people submit dupes just because they do not know. I think they need a little help (I'm in this category). Yes the humans filter well. But loads of links on new submissions page drags things out of attention of humans. Dupe links only help very little in this case. But spam does. I don't know why I see so many mozilla start page submissions in new submissions page (for example).